I don’t know why you have made this reference – please explain. I don’t see you can make a direct comparison like this.
BECAUSE YOU HAD IN THE MINERS STRIKE COMMUNITY IN STRUGGLE..HOW IS IT THAT DIFFERRENT??
I would state that the Republican w/c communities are more confident and so consequently are more empowered. The Republican Movement isn’t demoralised – quite the opposite, it is dynamic and forwardthinking. As for Loyalist working class communities – well, they seem in an awful state – insecure and paranoid, the peace dividend hasn’t brought them much in return. But then neither did the war dividend – I suspect that being involved and supporting Loyalist paramilitaries gave some return of importance and playing an important part, even if it was politically illusionary - how much have they gained for their loyalty??!
THE CATHLOLIC W/C ARE STILL ABOUT THE POOREST IN TH E Uk AS FAR AS I CAN SEE ... AND WOULD YOU HAVE LED DOWN THE ROUTE OF 30 YEARS OF BLOODSHED AND INCREASED SEGREGATION IF YOU HAD KNOWN IT WOULD LEAD TO THAT?? .. AS I SAID THE CRITIQUE OF ARMED STRUGGLE AND NATIONALISM QUITE CLEARLY SHOWS THAT INCREASED SEGREGATION AND BLOODSHED IS THE CONSEQUENCE OF NATIONALISM AND ARMED STRUGGLE
Okay, you’ve got me there – I haven’t read it, so can’t comment on its contents. But anyway, you point being?
DC!!
eAMONN MACANNS BOOK IS the MOST IMPORTANT BOOK ON THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT AND IT'S DESTRUCTION AND THE RISE OF NATIONALISM AND THE ARMED STRUGGLE!! ESSENTIAL READING .. IN BOTH EDITIONS .. AND MY POINT BEING HE SHOWS ( YES HE IS BIASED BUT HE WAS A KEY PERSON IN THE CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT) THAT NATIONALISM AND THE ARMED STRUGGLE WAS FORCED ON THE CATHOLICS BY THE MIDDLE CLASS ..
You say that it was the IRA that stopped the ‘w/c movement in NI’. I presume you mean Loyalists and Republicans in a united movement. For starters, there is little history of this happening – apart from radical Presbyterianism and for a brief time with the Revolutionary Workers Groups in the 30s. So it’s not as if their was any continuity in solidarity that was smashed by the arrival of the Provisionals. Besides anyway, everybody on the left – from the SDLP to the anarchists – declared that the root of the problem was partition – not message that has or never will ever go down well in the Skankill Road.
WHY IS THE ROOT OF THE PROBLEM PARTITION?? IT IS A PROBLEM BUT IF WE CAN NOT DEAL WITH BORDERS WITHOUT BECOMING NATIONALISTS WE ARE FKED .. THE ROOT OF THE PROBLEM IS CAPITALISM AND THE CLASS SYSTEM .. ONLY BY ATTACKING THAT CAN YOU DESTROY BORDERS
Of course, politically you are absolutely right – there does need to be a political working class movement in the Six Counties regardless of the religious make up or national allegiance (internationalism) or of its participants. But there is also reality – and a rather ugly one at that. The Sinn Fein Workers Party were an avowdley class-based Marxist party that never achieved a support of note in Northern Irish Republican communities, let alone in Loyalist ones.
TOO TRUE .. PARTLY THEY WERE DAFT STALINISTS .. ALSO THEY TRYING TO OUTDO THE PIRA AND SHOT A POPULAR KID FROM THE CREGGAN .. RANGER BEST .. FOR BEING IN THE BRITISH ARMY .. DESTROYED THEM IN DERRY .. BUT ONCE THE NATIONALIST AGENDA IS SET PEOPLE CAN DO LITTLE TO GET OUT OF IT ..
In many ways of course, your point is just political fantasising – what if? Even if this hyperthetical ‘what if’ doesn’t have much evidence to suggest that this route was ever plausible.