Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Donald Trump - MAGAtwat news and discussion

What’s “deserve” got to do with it? They exist and they will be saying this stuff. I’d rather they did it here where people can point out the ways it is wrong than on some other corner of the internet where they’ll find a willing audience

Go on, then. How should one approach the antisemitic contingent here?

Because phildwyer ,barlimo , _Russ_ don't seem to give a fuck about their bigotry and neither do those who regularly like their posts...

How is pointing out their wrongness making a difference?

Genuine question - not having a go.
 
The suggestion being that the Israeli lobby has a monumental influence on US politics. That's true. And he linked the article up before he was banned.

You haven’t answered the question of why you’re so convinced that you are an authority on antisemitism. Disproportionately to any expertise or discernment you claim on any other fraught topic on here.
 
Go on, then. How should one approach the antisemitic contingent here?
I’d say that urbanites do it jolly well, actually.
Because phildwyer ,barlimo , _Russ_ don't seem to give a fuck about their bigotry and neither do those who regularly like their posts...

How is pointing out their wrongness making a difference?

Genuine question - not having a go.
It’s making a difference to the much larger audience that read without posting or reacting. They see the posts and they see the challenge.
 
I'm not sure why you think that I think that. By the standards of these boards I'm very much pro-Israel. That doesn't mean that I don't think there's space to discuss what he introduced there.

This conversation, and shekelgate. Adamant in both cases.
 
Is that it?

One post asking LBJ a question?

No. These were your contributions in full to that particular discussion.

Seriously?

It's very well know slang/informal for money.

Are you very young (under 30)?

You’ve got this wrong, fella.

That's very different to "shekels" for money though, which is used in the same way as dough, dosh, dollar, quid, Bens, bread, brass ... etc.

Didn't know that, and it was only about an hour ago that I heard that Shekels is used pejoratively by anti-semites.

Is that for certain, or is this a U75 thing?

I think we did that one some time ago, also moron.

Apparently there are degrees of how much offence it's ok to take on this here website! :D ;)

Have Jews said this about Shekels, or is this people taking offence on their behalf?

I know many Jews and have never been made aware that it's an issue.

I was surprised at the time by how eager you were to argue the toss over it.
 
I was surprised at the time by how eager you were to argue the toss over it.

Still not sure how that leads you to suggest that I consider myself an authority on antisemitism. In one of the posts you’ve quoted there, I even say that I didn’t realise it was considered antisemitic.

I think you’ve got this wrong. I stand by all of that because it's thoroughly reasonable, but I don't remember posting it. You've clearly stuck in the bank because you're a bit burned that I disagreed with you.

I understand that.
 
Last edited:
What he posted was not antisemitic. As anyone who's actually read the Mearsheimer piece he referred to would realise.
Agree....Have read the Mearsheimer peice now....I think Mearsheimer is really tricky....I reach fairly similar conclusions to him on this and Ukraine but I don't agree with how he gets there...

Im not certain exactly what the difference is but i do think he leans towards conspiracy-like simplifications... Maybe the difference is lack of more traditional Marxist for want of a better word, understanding of people's/states motivations and behavoiur. In this case individuals being persuaded by lobbys rather than more systemic drivers.
Something like that... It's Friday night and can't come up with anything better to say.
 
Back
Top Bottom