Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Coronavirus - worldwide breaking news, discussion, stats, updates and more

Do the Chinese know something we don't?

I don't think Beijing knows any more about omicron than we do, but they've crushed dissent so thoroughly that authorities can pursue a zero COVID strategy at all costs without fear of repurcussions.

Many officials now believe that they must do everything within their power to ensure zero Covid infections since it is the will of their top leader, Xi Jinping. For the officials, virus control comes first. The people’s lives, well-being and dignity come much later.

The government has the help of a vast army of community workers who carry out the policy with zeal and hordes of online nationalists who attack anyone raising grievances or concerns.


 
Bizarre framing as usual from US coverage of covid in China, talking about virus control being put above people's lives, when not controlling the virus inevitably, even in the presence of mass vaccination leads to signifcantly more illness and death. Why would there be any significant dissent against a zero-Covid policy when the consequences of having Covid spread in other countries has been plain to see. Although it does neatly align with the argument from the state press that western style democracy is incapable of implementing the necessary Covid elimination strategies (which ignores the examples of democracies which did follow such a strategy).
 
Why would there be any significant dissent against a zero-Covid policy when the consequences of having Covid spread in other countries has been plain to see.

This could apply to every country, tbf.

China is pursuing its current COVID policy because it's a totalitarian state and it can get away with it - no country where the leaders had to worry about being elected would impose a total lockdown overnight on a city of 14 million people and tightly censor criticism.

Where Western countries might have gone wrong early in the pandemic is trying to bring in Wuhan-style lockdowns without the apparatus of dictatorship - it's a shame the press at the time wasn't taking a more critical look at the response of the Chinese state instead of gushing about how fast they built a prefab hospital.
 
Last edited:
This could apply to every country, tbf.
You'd hope so, but as much as governments have sometimes used it as an excuse, it's not on the whole been public opposition which has prevented governments putting in stricter measures, and often public opinion has overwhelming supported stricter measures than what governments have been willing to introduce. And AFAIK in countries like New Zealand that abandoned zero covid policies, it wasn't particularly a result of public opposition.
 
A better comparison might be Taiwan, where they've pursued a zero COVID strategy without the unaccountable brutality of the mainland government - I think the place that will have longer-term success in controlling COVID is the one where people aren't terrified of their government.
 
A better comparison might be Taiwan, where they've pursued a zero COVID strategy without the unaccountable brutality of the mainland government - I think the place that will have longer-term success in controlling COVID is the one where people aren't terrified of their government.
I honestly can't see the correlation, could you give some example regimes?
 
A better comparison might be Taiwan, where they've pursued a zero COVID strategy without the unaccountable brutality of the mainland government - I think the place that will have longer-term success in controlling COVID is the one where people aren't terrified of their government.
I don't have an overall picture of how things have gone in Taiwan, but I think early on they were sealing people into their homes.
 
Just saw this fb post from Trudeau

Justin Trudeau​



Update: It is now illegal to intimidate doctors, nurses, and patients – or to obstruct them from providing care or seeking treatment – as our government’s legislation to criminalize this behaviour comes into force today. We’ll continue to have the backs of health care workers

Several of the comments are that the government can not force them to take the vaccine - well d'uh...
 
I don't have an overall picture of how things have gone in Taiwan, but I think early on they were sealing people into their homes.

That only happened in mainland China, AFAIK - maybe you saw a story from Taiwanese media, which reports more openly on developments on the mainland?

 
I honestly can't see the correlation, could you give some example regimes?

Beyond Taiwan, Japan and South Korea are also democratic countries that have seen very high levels of compliance with public health measures.

While China also has very high levels of compliance, I think extreme measures like locking down entire cities for weeks so tightly that people are having trouble getting food is likely to make at least a few people so terrified of the consequences of testing positive that they will either ignore their symptoms or persuade themselves that they couldn't possibly be infected.

Chinese authorities seem to be in denial themselves - there's an omicron outbreak in Tianjin, 80 miles from Beijing and less than 30 minutes away by train, but authorities are claiming a case of omicron detected in Beijing must have come from the surface of a package that was sent from Toronto and passed through the US and Hong Kong in its four-day journey to China.

 
In Hong Kong, they're culling thousands of hamsters - after a woman who works in a pet shop tested positive for delta and they couldn't find a human source, they tested the hamsters and 11 came back positive.

Seems just as likely that delta was circulating undetected and the woman infected the hamsters, guess we will find out in the weeks to come.

 
A bit of a derail but I wonder whether covid might help put into perspective some of the other threats and how seriously we should take them:


More than 1.2 million – and potentially millions more – died in 2019 as a direct result of antibiotic-resistant bacterial infections, according to the most comprehensive estimate to date of the global impact of antimicrobial resistance (AMR).

There seem to be relatively easy things that can be done with that though - stop force feeding animals with antibiotics in the US particularly, for example.
 
This thread started with this post two years ago today - feels like a fuck of a lot longer.
23 January 2020 my son messaged from China to say they were fine, nervously following the news, but that 400 people had already flown into their city from Wuhan for the Chinese New Year holidays.
 
According to several articles, Chinese social media hates Canada.

They claim we sent them covid-infected mail.

:(
Mostly thats as a result of the latest evolution of their propaganda which has sought to blame other countries for Covid. A new variant of the propaganda they've used to deflect away from their role in the pandemic arriving in the first place.
 
Mostly thats as a result of the latest evolution of their propaganda which has sought to blame other countries for Covid. A new variant of the propaganda they've used to deflect away from their role in the pandemic arriving in the first place.


I think it may have more to do with us holding a Chinese CFO(?) for several years while the US decided whether or not to extradite her.

On that count, I agree with them.
 
Back
Top Bottom