I think that this meshes in with
brogdale's point about
shitholes/nice places - for me (university educated, middle class, middle aged, white, from the Cotswolds) Oxford should be the epitome of 'nice place': it's beautiful, fantastic architecture, beautiful parks and gardens, museums etc... but here's the rub, for me it's a shithole because while it does have all those things, it's also horrifically busy, ruinously expensive, and apart from the museum's and gardens, most of the fantastic buildings are off limits to visitors. It's also
crawling with people affecting a particular type of dress, behaviour and speech.
After an hour of Oxford I've had enough.
I'll offer another example of the
shithole/not shithole falacy: the nearest large town to me on Kidderminster, the town centre is a bit of a tip,
skidderminster is the butt of many jokes - and in truth I doubt many people book 2 week holidays there - but it has good schools, low crime rates, easy access to the motorway network, and you can buy a 1930's 3 bed semi with a big garden and within half a mile of open countryside and forest for £170k.
Kiddy will never win any beautiful town competitions, but i'll bet that for many people who lived in London, or Birmingham, or Manchester during lockdown, they'd have happily up sticks to Kidderminster and paid handsomely for it of they'd have been able to see past the 'crap towns' reputation....