Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Brexit or Bremain - Urban votes

EU

  • Brexit

  • Bremain

  • Abstain


Results are only viewable after voting.
Vote between two different ways of the same people fucking us up. Hmmmm.
Won't be bothering; not sure I can even be arsed to go and spoil my paper.
 
No that whole post was responding to the nonsense posted by DrRingDing. I just quoted part of your post as an example of a reason why someone might vote for remain.


Cheers for that, and I do see now.

I posted my question about 6:30 am yesterday ... I'm never very good at working mornibgs :oops:
 
Look at the remain voters that have posted on U75, I've not seen anyway arguing for such nonsense.

I don't agree with the arguments of those voting to remain but to claim that they are voting for less democracy is the reverse of the moronic argument that a vote for leave for nationalism.
They may not have that uppermost in mind - but that is undoubtedly the outcome of remaining.
People are voting for remain for all sorts of reasons, many people because of something like this others because they think the EU will protect some workers rights, others because they feel 'European', some because they support the neo-liberalism of the EU, some because they are worried about what they think might happen to friends and loved ones who aren't British citizens and lots because they would rather just stick with the devil they know.
Indeed - and many will be voting to remain as a result of the high level of scaremongering tactics employed by Cameron and Co. without even examining the plausibility of such claims.
 
They may not have that uppermost in mind - but that is undoubtedly the outcome of remaining.
That is as it may be, but you don't see massive movements in France & Germany to exit the EU, rather they are getting stuck in to make it how they want it. Something I think we should be doing also.
 
Leaked TTIP documents cast doubt on EU-US trade deal

Technical barriers to trade only really has 3 justifications for not adopting global standard : national security, H&S and Environmental, is looking like TTIP is about stripping environmental to a global standard . (pity i kind of like bees and stuff).


The EFTA out model leaves UK with government by fax in Enviornment and H&S (National Security is more complicated (look how quickly the US Safe Harbour was worked out). Personally I was happy with that as a nation we are a bit knuckle draggy over those issues.
 
That is as it may be, but you don't see massive movements in France & Germany to exit the EU, rather they are getting stuck in to make it how they want it. Something I think we should be doing also.

I think the French/Germans and just about eveyone else would be rather pissed off if we started telling them what they should do about the EUro and Schengen.

Besides, the French are on hold for a year as they try to make Juppe President rather than Le Pen (who has some very different ideas about what she wants) and what Germany seems to want is Nein zu Allem.
 
Indeed - and many will be voting to remain as a result of the high level of scaremongering tactics employed by Cameron and Co. without even examining the plausibility of such claims.

True there's been scaremongering. All the same, that point would be more persuasive to me if it wasn't for the sheer volumes of outright lies put out by the Brexit lot. Hardly makes their efforts to contradict the Remain side's points very effective.
 
That is as it may be, but you don't see massive movements in France & Germany to exit the EU, rather they are getting stuck in to make it how they want it. Something I think we should be doing also.
So what? They are two of the founding members - and exacted a heavy price from Heath when they 'allowed' the UK . In addition, France in particular, but also Germany, unlike ourselves, do very well out of the CAP - which even now consumes something like 40% of the EU budget.
 
True there's been scaremongering. All the same, that point would be more persuasive to me if it wasn't for the sheer volumes of outright lies put out by the Brexit lot. Hardly makes their efforts to contradict the Remain side's points very effective.
Well perhaps instead of bleating 'outright lies', you could be more precise, and inform everyone what these lies are?
 
So what? They are two of the founding members - and exacted a heavy price from Heath when they 'allowed' the UK . In addition, France in particular, but also Germany, unlike ourselves, do very well out of the CAP - which even now consumes something like 40% of the EU budget.
We certainly won't rectify that through leaving.
 
Stevlin : I take it you're a Brexiter? ;)
Indeed William........I guess that must be obvious from my comments. Leaving will undoubtedly 'rectify that' as far as the UK are concerned though - which I believe is far more important. ;0)
Trade with the EU would still continue - and we might even be able to afford treating British cancer patients who are being denied life extending drugs because of the expense!!
 
Indeed William........I guess that must be obvious from my comments. Leaving will undoubtedly 'rectify that' as far as the UK are concerned though - which I believe is far more important. ;0)
Trade with the EU would still continue - and we might even be able to afford treating British cancer patients who are being denied life extending drugs because of the expense!!

Can you explain how this works and why leaving the EU would make these drugs more affordable (I'm guessing this is what you mean, although it's not totally clear)
 
Trade with the EU would still continue - and we might even be able to afford treating British cancer patients who are being denied life extending drugs because of the expense!!
I don't think we are likely to be able to negotiate access to the single market post exit without having to abide by the rules and more significantly, paying for access. Even taking into account that France and Germany will still want to access the UK market.

And welcome to Urban, Stevlin.
 
Can you explain how this works and why leaving the EU would make these drugs more affordable (I'm guessing this is what you mean, although it's not totally clear)
I would have thought that fairly clear Andy - we currently borrow about £1 billion per month ,(net), to pay our EU membership fee/EU subsidy , yet cannot afford certain drugs......so out of the EU, if we can afford to subsidise them each year, we could continue to borrow it to fund those drugs instead.
I'm talking possibility of course - if we do leave the EU, despite not having to borrow the EU subsidy, I wouldn't be surprised if the response for those drugs would still be - "too expensive"
 
I don't think we are likely to be able to negotiate access to the single market post exit without having to abide by the rules and more significantly, paying for access. Even taking into account that France and Germany will still want to access the UK market.
And welcome to Urban, Stevlin.
Well around 50 or so countries have in fact arranged just that......and as the EU sells more to the UK than vice versa, it would clearly hurt them more than the UK. In any event, the average global trade tariff is far lower now that it was in 1973 - which to a certain extent has actually 'devalued' free trade agreements. But, although we access the single market, it cannot really be considered 'free' , as we have to pay a subsidy for that privilege----as well as handing over British sole fishing territorial rights to the EU, and ceding some of our sovereignty, ( EU law has primacy over UK Parliament law), to an unelected politburo, and irresponsibly ceding control of our borders.

And thank you for the welcome WW - it is appreciated.
 
I would have thought that fairly clear Andy - we currently borrow about £1 billion per month ,(net), to pay our EU membership fee/EU subsidy , yet cannot afford certain drugs......so out of the EU, if we can afford to subsidise them each year, we could continue to borrow it to fund those drugs instead.
I'm talking possibility of course - if we do leave the EU, despite not having to borrow the EU subsidy, I wouldn't be surprised if the response for those drugs would still be - "too expensive"
This is silly argument, we leave the EU but still have the same amount to spend - so we can spend it on stuff like cancer drugs(who wouldn't want that?) instead of the useless EU...
 
If you take ALL the money we pay in to spend on cancer drugs, you've collapsed agriculture let alone the other areas money comes back, and you can't compensate the fishermen you don't want fishing your waters (A legal requirement). It a lot more the 50 countries that don't get billed for single market access.

In the Seven Years War, we had a vital need for experienced sailors. Still made more sense to shoot Admiral Byng.
 
Stevlin : do you think the main thrust of the Brexit campaign right now, is advancing your case very well?
Unfortunately, I believe that there is a strong possibility that the Bremainers will will the referendum. I consider the leave campaign to be extremely sensible, based on what the situation IS now. The future of the EU is undoubtedly the USSE - common currency, lack of borders, Parliament etc....
Personally, I much prefer that we manage our own destiny - which we have for far longer than we have been in the EEC/EU........but , the British public are generally very apathetic wrt politics - and those outlandish scare mongering tales appear to be scaring many people!!
The Bremainers cannot even see the dangers incorporated in the free - movement right of an expanding political union. Just look at our prison population! We have enough home grown criminals without importing them - and soon, there will be another 5 countries, making it 32 European, ( plus mostly Asian Turkey), with the right to walk into the UK.
Absolute bonkers!!
 
This is silly argument, we leave the EU but still have the same amount to spend - so we can spend it on stuff like cancer drugs(who wouldn't want that?) instead of the useless EU...
OK clever clogs - now tell us why the argument is 'silly'. We are IN the EU, which means we CANNOT spend the 'same amount' AND buy those cancer drugs - but not everybody supports Brexit do they?
 
OK clever clogs - now tell us why the argument is 'silly'. We are IN the EU, which means we CANNOT spend the 'same amount' AND buy those cancer drugs - but not everybody supports Brexit do they?
it went silly when you added numbers. (and has been going down hill since)
 
Stevlin : Thanks for that reply.

(I'll be back on this thread ASAP but I need to crash early, tonight)

None of your reply really answered my question though -- how well are Brexit actually doing, publicity-wise, and in pragmatic election-strategy terms, at advancing any sensible arguments to leave the EU??

:hmm:
 
In other words : IMO, Brexiters come over as demented obsessives in current publicity.

That's a big terrible mainstreammedia conspiracy presumably ;)
 
OK clever clogs - now tell us why the argument is 'silly'. We are IN the EU, which means we CANNOT spend the 'same amount' AND buy those cancer drugs - but not everybody supports Brexit do they?
It's a false equivalent to say the reason we don't buy them is because we have to pay for membership of the EU.
 
Back
Top Bottom