I watched both seasons over the last five days. Enjoyed it a lot, Anthony Starr as Homelander is outstanding, what an utterly loathsome (cunty) villain/hero. Both Hugh and Annie/Starlight are genuinely likeable as the star crossed lovers, I kept rooting for them. The only character where I rolled my eyes is Billy Butcher and it's not just the accent. I'm just tired of that type of macho cockney geezer character. At least Annie gets to call him out on his bullshit by season 2. The other thing which always bothers me,, is when Toronto is asked to play New York, which it never does convincingly, but it's an understandable budgetary measure. I agree with T&P that at times the pace was a little slack. Otherwise pretty good, though not as good as the Watchmen tv series.