Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Will you vote for independence?

Scottish independence?

  • Yes please

    Votes: 99 56.6%
  • No thanks

    Votes: 57 32.6%
  • Dont know yet

    Votes: 17 9.7%

  • Total voters
    175
Getting into the area I said I would post on in the middle of the month, still will,, though am going to have to write to my MP and MSP for some clarifcations as well.
Yes you could still do banking, but the loans you have, (average Scot has £20,000 of personal debt) it will according to NO be in a different currency and therefore vulnerable to fluctuations. A forced shotgun currency union as wanted by Salmond, is possible, through a Sorosesque Black Wednesday event-that got us out the ERM interest rates rose 3% in a day. I would hope Yes will have blinked before the speculators arrive however.



EU regs mean the banks would have to move south of the border due to most of their business being based in London
Which regs exactly?
 
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-26455655
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31995L0026:EN:HTML

our company lost a similar sort of thing in aviation in ICAO around a similar time.

That debt figure came from typing average personal debt Scotland into google . debt support trust outline of link that is top ranking for me. Would include mortguages i would guess, as the UK average is £59,000, their aren't enough mad bank managers to dish out unsecured loans at that rate
 
Last edited:
It might be the mean personal debt, but I doubt it's the mode. As you say, it probably includes mortgages, too.

However, my bank is Santander. It offers me loans. Often good rates, too. And its home currency is the euro while mine is Sterling. Oh noes.

This is a non story about a non subject by people who are dazzled by the fancy wrapper on the trinkets. Ooh, it says Scotland on the tin. That Must Be Important.
 
Agreed, it won't matter, at least initially, as Dave & co have said that Scotland won't be in the EU.
 
Your bank Can issue loans in any currency pulling a figure from things air95 percent of UK Loans are currently in pounds.
Fucking non story Salmond I banking on a black Wednesday and it's a non story. Expect the I'm english should I give a fuck to fill up if and when
 
Agreed, it won't matter, at least initially, as Dave & co have said that Scotland won't be in the EU.
You've lost me. What have Dave & Co got to do with a) reality, in this discussion b) whether Scotland would be in the EU, c) the effect of the registered office of a bank being in a different country to the branch you use?
 
Your bank Can issue loans in any currency pulling a figure from things air95 percent of UK Loans are currently in pounds.
Fucking non story Salmond I banking on a black Wednesday and it's a non story. Expect the I'm english should I give a fuck to fill up if and when
Are you at the fridge magnet poetry again, Dave? It's a bit 70s. Where do you keep the Brit?
 
an independence debate at Broughton High School in Edinburgh tonight

broughton.jpg

I'd like to think the packed-out nature of these debates is a good sign for the vote turnout.
 
Have you met anyone who doesn't have something to say about it? I think it's the most-discussed issue I've ever encountered.

We've just got a staff forum at work and in the email from the manager giving us a log-in and a password he says

Staff and social forum
This forum is designed to allow staff to talk about events, invite people to events, share pictures and stories about events or even just chat freely about anything you wish (within reason). You can start a debate about Scottish independence, the good and bad of doping in cycling or the make up of the X-factor panel.
 
Plenty of people. Possibly because I have a strong English accent (pretty much RP).
I've not found that to be a barrier myself. Many of those who offer me a view on the referendum have English accents.

Indeed Mrs La Rouge has an English accent (on account of being English). She tells me many people wish to discuss the referendum with her.
 
Does anyone worry as I do that elections are probably as likely to be rigged here as they are on say Florida or Afghanistan Kiev or the Crimea or anywhere else for that matter. Is Scottish independence about the people or is it about what the ruling classes want. Does it really matter what the people think if there is no "real Democratic process"?

Just a thought. Worth thinking about though eh?
 
Does anyone worry as I do that elections are probably as likely to be rigged here

No. We have a civil service that is still largely professional and politically independent. And the independence vote will be the most heavily scrutinised in Scotland's history.
 
No. We have a civil service that is still largely professional and politically independent. And the independence vote will be the most heavily scrutinised in Scotland's history.

Is that the same civil service that was involved with that Libyan chap who was accused of blowing up a certain airliner over Lockerbie? Is he dead yet?

To what extent has this impeccable civil service that's just a tired hangover of the old Scottish Office been involved in investigating the Holly Greig Scandal? Most irregular all that eh?

This civil service let me down recently by refusing to investigate the huge misappropriation of public funds in the west of Scotland in a social housing project. I'm sure this issue can be extrapolated out to numerous money pits around the nation making private companies rich with public money.

I like that fall song about the civil servant? Do you?

Everybody knows the civil service in Britain is full of very dodgy people. I'm particularly fond of those at the dole. Well aren't we all, those that know their bum hole from their elbow anyway.

Why would you want to defend them? Are you well informed about something everyone else is unaware of or are you connected with them in some way? Or are you just unusually positive about that which is clearly questionable?

I'm sorry to disagree with you but my experience of the civil service is a bad one. TBF though about twenty years ago the tax lot weren't too bad. Now they are dreadful.

So do you think Scottish civil servants are immune from doing as their masters dictate?

I think it's a bit naive to think that Scotland has any autonomy right now or that it ever will have, to any real extent.

Ask the Irish after their bail out, who is pulling the strings over in Dublin these days.

Things are always as they want us to see them. The establishment control the full spectrum of the audio visual and printed media as well as the press. There are no independent journalists. People are tortured by the UK Government, murdered, they go missing etc. Britain is a pawn used by America on the international game board isn't it? Where does Scottish independence fit into that? Oh dear I feel another trump coming on. Excuse me please!

Do you honestly think if they can wage illegal wars that they give a monkeys what the people think. Good god! They tell the people what to think.

I don't think I'll bother voting in Britain ever again. It's a total farce. You only have to consider Thatchers length of office to see that.
 
I have concerns about an honest vote count tbh. I hope that it will be accurate and honest, and I believe that it will become very well scrutinised as Quartz writes, if people aren't happy. They moved the goalposts in 79, I'm not sure they would get away with that again. I bloody hope not :)

I will continue to vote but only because I have an alternative to the three Tory parties.

And yes Megrahi died in 2012. I didn't believe he did it at the time, and I still don't.
 
I have concerns about an honest vote count tbh. I hope that it will be accurate and honest, and I believe that it will become very well scrutinised as Quartz writes, if people aren't happy. They moved the goalposts in 79, I'm not sure they would get away with that again. I bloody hope not :)

I will continue to vote but only because I have an alternative to the three Tory parties.

And yes Megrahi died in 2012. I didn't believe he did it at the time, and I still don't.

As far as Megrahi is concerned doesn't that just illustrate how Scotland will just do as it's told on a wider world stage? How will an Independant Scotland be manipulated?

There are no alternatives to Tory all parties need to follow the right wing orders of their corporate masters. If you see an alternative in the SNP I would like to learn more about that? Socialism is dead in the UK as are the options of any third way. The peoples creativity to organise themselves and make expectations of the establishment in the absence of any true democratic representation is all the hope that is left. Mass demonstration and industrial action would be a good start.

For all it professes to be a conglomerate party composed of an eclectic mix of the left right and centre ground, any contact I've had with it suggests that the SNP is an over officious right wing organisation that is power thirsty. Dictatorial and didactic, failing in its responsibility to scrutinise anything beyond the central belt or anything that doesn't fit into its short term I'll conceived race towards independence. They don't want Independence for our benefit, they want it for their benefit. They aren't the noble statesmen of old. Acting out of patriotism for a nation that they serve. They are just mobsters.

You will end up with a puppet government whatever the outcome. Policy will be driven by the same forces that drive them now and nothing will change. Independent or not, Westminster will always seek to have its way with Scotland and I don't think independence will change this in any way. Whether it's right or wrong those with the greater power will have their way and they will write the history books.

The supposed democratic "West" is at the whim of its Central banks, American foreign policy and the strength of the Dollar. Westminster dilly dallies between alignment between Brussels and Washington. Why would an independent Scotland be any different? What clout will it have? What all important GDP figure will it achieve to make it a successful financial player? How much time will it spend quarrelling
with Westminster over the use of highland regiments in England's military commitment in the Middle East etc etc. Gods teeth imagine the shenanigans and scandals and cover ups that will go on in the constancy back biting between Edinburgh and Westminster! Dear god it's bad enough as it is.

Alex Salmond and his cronies will be subject to the same market forces as the UK is now. An Independent Scotland has no different a hand at the poker table than it does now. The power dreams of the SNP will drag a nation into problem after problem and Westminster will watch like a vulture waiting for any pickings.

The romance of the brave heart mentality will do Scotland no favours you can't call that story a victory any more than Llewelyn ap Gruffudds stand against the English. Or Britains dismal failure at Dunkirk!

Heads on spikes at traitors gate. That's all that came from all that.

If people in Britain including Scotland want a new way then they have to demand it as a unified nation all Britons together with a common purpose. Separatism and fragmentation of the british people will only make it easier for the corporate and banking classes to carve up the joint as they see fit.

Sadly Scotland missed its chance for independence as Wales did hundreds of years ago. All this devolution stuff is just a distraction from real issues.

Like the Sun with its dangerous dog and alien encounter/ celebrity stories and discovery channel with snake eating shark week etc. It's just soma for the masses. There are great wrongs happening in the real world that require our attention! Wake up and feel the piss running down your neck! It is not raining!
 
If you see an alternative in the SNP I would like to learn more about that? Socialism is dead in the UK as are the options of any third way.

Do you live in Scotland? How is free prescriptions, free healthcare, bus passes for over 60s and free higher education right wing? There are other parties out there, all over the UK that are not right wing. Ok they maybe need more support but they are out there. I suggest you look for them.

You have some very strange ideas but you are entitled to your own opinion. I suggest you read the whole thread(there's loads of links to relevant info) and look at google if you want to learn about the SNP. While you're at it it might be worth looking up Plaid Cymru, who are also very right wing, not!
 
I won't vote for independence. I think it's the foolish idea yet... and all the economy of Scotland is dependent on the UK's. If Scotland went independent, it wouldn't be able to survive on only tourism.
 
Back
Top Bottom