Reno
The In Kraut
The scene in room 237 comes from the novel it's an adaptation of. Danny gets hurt by the ghost despite having been told by Halloran to stay away from it and later Jack investigates room 237 and encounters a ghost for the first time himself. One could argue that scene suffers from having been taken from its context in the novel where that female ghost is a larger character with a back story. Kubrick makes it more ambiguous by having the ghosts be a possible extension of Jack's declining mental state but only to a certain point. I think it works for the film, which could not have adapted all of what is a very long novel. While Kubrick plays down the supernatural elements from the novel, they are still there. It's a story about a haunted hotel full of the ghosts of former occupants who now haunt it, so I don't see why the woman in room 237 is random.I agree it was an effective scene. But in context how does it fit into the story? And if it doesn't what does it symbolise? If it's there to just scare then I'm annoyed whether or not it's effective. Kubrick did some great war films, he seemed to get it with those, but I'm glad this was his only horror. Random scares are the hallmark of bad horror, all the best horror films have a bit of intellect to them even if they have the reputation that they don't.
Last edited: