Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Rojava Kurdistan, Murray Bookchin and regional Kurdish politics

Nothing particularly new but with the YPG moving onto more mixed areas under the SDF flag this stuff is worth bearing in mind - esp around Manbij in coming months. Not to mentiuon what relations with the FSA and others are going to be established in Aleppo.

Rojava: A libertarian myth under scrutiny

The emphasis on ethno-sectarian identities is further echoed in the foundational statement of the Federal Democratic System, which is based on the representation of "community components".

As Syrian intellectual Jad Karim Jibai pointed out: "Nobody knows how an 'entity', that is 'peoples and communities' (ie, clans and ethno-sectarian communities), could transcend national borders."
Click to expand...

In other words, the insistence on these communitarian boundaries betrays the libertarian transnational aspirations.

This contradiction is also evident from the authority bestowed upon tribal leaders. For instance Shaykh Humaydi Daham al-Jarba, the head of a tribal Arab militia and an outspoken supporter of the Assad regime, was appointed as the governor of the Jazirah canton in Rojava in 2014.
Click to expand...
 
butchersapron said:
Nothing particularly new but with the YPG moving onto more mixed areas under the SDF flag this stuff is worth bearing in mind - esp around Manbij in coming months. Not to mentiuon what relations with the FSA and others are going to be established in Aleppo.

Rojava: A libertarian myth under scrutiny
Click to expand...

The contents are I am sure true - coordinating with village leaders/tribal leaders in Arab areas, but this is an empty dig and the 'using child soldiers' angle is overblown.

However, the militarisation of women and society at large is an alarming trend enforced through conscription and sanctioned by the social prestige enjoyed by the fighters' families. In fact, only the "martyrs"' pictures are "venerated" with the same devoutness of Ocalan's icons.

Consequently, women become worthy of respect as long as they turn into men of arms and sacrifice themselves on the battlefield.

Some would defend this militarised system of values with the current need to defend Rojava, but to assume that even minors should be forcibly enlisted to ensure the survival of a social utopia is a disturbing argument to say the least.

The link as evidence of minors being forcibly enlisted http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2013/06/syria-kurds-pyd-youth-civil-society.html
states that

However, the former street kids praise the values of the only "diploma" they have ever obtained. Malek said, “Here, I understood the meaning of life and I’ve learned brotherhood. Inside a family there might be disputes, but a comrade is closer than a brother."
"We’ve learned self-criticism to avoid quarrels among us,” Hamid affirmed. All of the young YPG soldiers interviewed by Al-Monitor claimed to be volunteers.

Looking at it in the round, the "militarised system of values" of the Kurdish national movement has massively decreased since the early 1990s.


It should also be noted that European leftist solidarity cherry-picked the so-called Rojava revolution, whereas other revolutionary theorists, such as Omar Aziz in Damascus, went completely ignored, because they were neither endorsed by one of the best equipped militias in the region such as the PKK, nor did they phrase their social utopia according to a libertarian terminology.

That is an odd slur aswell what solidarity could exactly be given to Omar Aziz above and beyond the solidarity to the other thousands in Syrian prisons?
 
butchersapron said:
Allowing is the wrong word - participating and encouraging it for the ethnic benefit of post-war doings is nearer.
Click to expand...

Report also says that the YPG will be being trained by Russian forces. I assume that this must mean the imminent withdrawal of US trainers?
 
J Ed said:
Report also says that the YPG will be being trained by Russian forces. I assume that this must mean the imminent withdrawal of US trainers?
Click to expand...
Don't see why. Any US training is going on far away from afrin - and basically involves learning how to call in air-strikes. There is no US/Russia clash -they're both on the same page. Prop up Assad. One by attacking any armed rebels - and so, any of the democratic responses left - and one by limiting any support to only people fighting ISIS. The common end is to make it - as assad aimed all along - into a secular state (i.e what's left of the SAA - an almost wholly shia jihadist army by now) Vs a sunni jihadi fight - at least in how it can be sold.
 
Both Hezbollah commanders say they have collaborated with the Syrian Kurdish militia, the People’s Protection Units (YPG), in areas where they have common interests against the rebels. Commander Bakr claims that, at times over the past year, Hezbollah directly coordinated with the US-backed leftist Kurdish liberation forces as they advanced along Turkey’s border.

“We share intel…everything,” he says of Hezbollah’s cooperation with the YPG in Aleppo province. “These people will take from whoever will serve their interests.”

Kurdish forces control vast tracts of territory in northern Syria, where they have implemented a program of radical local democracy—and where they have also been accused of expulsions against Arab Syrians and human-rights abuses against Arabs as well as Kurdish political opponents. Originally supportive of the Syrian Revolution and still officially opposed to the Assad regime, the YPG has focused on taking control of Kurdish areas and fighting the Islamic State (ISIS, or Daesh). It has rarely fought against regime forces.
Click to expand...
 
This is how it ends then:


c56b110d934363d824c0d872747544d5.jpg


Afrin today. Regime flags flying over ypg controlled borders as well.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile this got published yesterday from The Middle East Center for Reporting and Analysis which I imagine would be of interest to people on this thread:

A visit to the Jazeera Canton:
Report and assessment

This report is based on the author’s trip in January 2018 to the Jazeera Canton area of the Democratic Federation of Northern Syria in the northeast of Syria. The visit particularly focused on the city of Qamishli on the border with Turkey. All featured photos are the author’s own....
Click to expand...
 
teqniq said:
Meanwhile this got published yesterday from The Middle East Center for Reporting and Analysis which I imagine would be of interest to people on this thread:

A visit to the Jazeera Canton:
Report and assessment
Click to expand...
Thanks. Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi does incredibly detailed (if often repetitive) reports and research on often ignored or minor aspects of the conflict - all of which are really useful and will become increasingly so in reconstructing things at a later date. But over the last few years he seems to have developed a real haughtiness towards others working in the same field - esp those who come down more in support of the anti-assad opposition (note: i'm not saying that he's an assad shill or anything) and seems to be concerned with knocking them out of the arena leaving him alone. He esp seems to despise lister and i think genuinely wants to drive to to disengage entirely.

Quick skim of the report (which ill read in full later) has him not backing down from highlighting the reliance on the regime across a range of activities without agreeing that it's 'parasitic' on the regime but also saying it cannot ever operate as an anti-regime force.
 
Yeah I've only skimmed it myself what I did notice though is that some public employees are still paid by the regime and it seems that they can choose who they get paid by.
 
butchersapron said:
This is how it ends then:
Click to expand...

Regime will fight Turkish armed forces, US will not.
From the Kurdish nationalist perspective it's another intermediary stage.

I am out of the loop, I read something very convincing about Syrian opposition rebel areas being far worse for women than regime areas but lost the link.

I see no path for progress treachery and pain on all sides- our era's Lebanon.
 
Has he been engaging in denial? I am disappointed if so. The situation there is a whole lot more complicated there than sometimes I think we appreciate.
 
A related/side thing:

teqniq said:
Meanwhile this got published yesterday from The Middle East Center for Reporting and Analysis which I imagine would be of interest to people on this thread:

A visit to the Jazeera Canton:
Report and assessment
Click to expand...

butchersapron said:
Thanks. Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi does incredibly detailed (if often repetitive) reports and research on often ignored or minor aspects of the conflict - all of which are really useful and will become increasingly so in reconstructing things at a later date. But over the last few years he seems to have developed a real haughtiness towards others working in the same field - esp those who come down more in support of the anti-assad opposition (note: i'm not saying that he's an assad shill or anything) and seems to be concerned with knocking them out of the arena leaving him alone. He esp seems to despise lister and i think genuinely wants to drive to to disengage entirely.

Quick skim of the report (which ill read in full later) has him not backing down from highlighting the reliance on the regime across a range of activities without agreeing that it's 'parasitic' on the regime but also saying it cannot ever operate as an anti-regime force.
Click to expand...

Not surprised this has happened to be honest, surprised it hadn't happened already if anything.

Statement: Seizure of my Laptop and Mobile

Readers may have noticed a sudden halt in my public writings as of 9 December. The reason for this halt has been the seizure of my work laptop and mobile phone by the UK counter-terrorism (CT) police. As a media guy/researcher working on sensitive topics as regards security and terrorism (primarily Syria, Iraq and the Islamic State), I have been used to questioning by security services about my work and travel in various places. The treatment by the UK CT police, however, is by far the worst I have ever received.http://www.aymennjawad.org/2019/12/statement-seizure-of-my-laptop-and-mobile
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

T
definition of left and right wing of politics
Replies
23
Views
1K
Nigel
Nigel
Nikkormat
Czech politics
Replies
4
Views
489
Nikkormat
Nikkormat
Yuwipi Woman
Political violence in the USA
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
243
Views
16K
two sheds
two sheds
I
Political crisis, institutional decline, conspiracism, right wing radicalism: what's going on, where's it going, is there an answer?
2 3
Replies
74
Views
4K
yield
Y
T & P
Why is so politically significant for US TV networks to call election results?
Replies
12
Views
706
Jennaonthebeach
Jennaonthebeach
Back
Top Bottom