Roger Waters self indulgent twat / not self indulgent twat
- Thread starter Firky
- Start date
Fair enough. It sounds like it should be on The Final Cut though.It’s on Amused to Death
(I only listened to it yesterday)
Idris2002
canadian girlfriend
??? No it's not?
Yes we’ve established that.
Idris2002
canadian girlfriend
Thank god I have lived to see this day
Yossarian
⏭️
After his incredibly ignorant remarks about China and Taiwan last year I'd struggle to take anything the twat says on any subject seriously.
Orang Utan
Psychick Worrier Ov Geyoor
I think he’s a cunt
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
think he's taken the we don't need no education a bit far
Idris2002
canadian girlfriend
hash tag
Books, not bombs
So eloquently put as well.
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
But do you think that makes him a cunt?
But does that make him a cunt?
Maybe he shagged Orang Utan ’s Nan and then stopped taking her calls 
i can't believe that so much attention is being given to Roger Waters being a cunt or not . Its almost as if we have endless time to waste and that there are not more pressing and interesting matters to debate. For eg, is Sir Paul McCartney a cunt for trying to airbrush Lennon out of the history of the Beatles?
I think it should go without saying that cunts are complex. There's a series of interviews with Waters, Wright, Gilmore and Mason that you can find on youtube, mainly with respect to Sid Barrett and what happened to him. I watched all these a few years back because... because well fixation with Barrett that I'm not necessarily particularly proud about. But anyway my impressions on the personalities of the four
Wright just comes across as distant and uncomfortable being interviewed
Gilmore comes across as thoughtful and relatively humble
Mason comes across as a "brutally honest" type and frankly pretty heartless
Waters comes across as a big, forceful personality who's also very emotional (he broke down in tears) and basically caring
I kinda liked Waters in that interview but he's very wedded to the dubious "Sid was an acid casualty" theory and is very much the type who has no self-doubt. I could imagine he's a very decent guy if you knew him. Most of the time. But that's tempered by a big ego and I don't know quite what happens when someone challenges that ego - I guess his band mates eventually found out. But it's not surprising that he's a) into left wing politics and b) doing it really badly. And really it's as a public figure that we know him anyway, so maybe his heart is in the right place in some sense but in some ways that just makes it worse.
Wright just comes across as distant and uncomfortable being interviewed
Gilmore comes across as thoughtful and relatively humble
Mason comes across as a "brutally honest" type and frankly pretty heartless
Waters comes across as a big, forceful personality who's also very emotional (he broke down in tears) and basically caring
I kinda liked Waters in that interview but he's very wedded to the dubious "Sid was an acid casualty" theory and is very much the type who has no self-doubt. I could imagine he's a very decent guy if you knew him. Most of the time. But that's tempered by a big ego and I don't know quite what happens when someone challenges that ego - I guess his band mates eventually found out. But it's not surprising that he's a) into left wing politics and b) doing it really badly. And really it's as a public figure that we know him anyway, so maybe his heart is in the right place in some sense but in some ways that just makes it worse.
danny la rouge
More like *fanny* la rouge!
Has Paul McCartney re-recorded Sgt Peppers on his own in order to rid it of the other Beatles’ contributions?
Exactly.
This isn’t new though. He did the original Berlin gig of The Wall using talent that wasn’t other band members.Has Paul McCartney re-recorded Sgt Peppers on his own in order to rid it of the other Beatles’ contributions?
Exactly.
Likewise Pink Floyd have played gigs using material he wrote without him.
danny la rouge
More like *fanny* la rouge!
That’s gigs, though. Bit different from re-recording a classic album (Dark Side of the Moon).
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
no, i think he was a cunt before that
Not yet.Has Paul McCartney re-recorded Sgt Peppers on his own in order to rid it of the other Beatles’ contributions?
Exactly.
SpookyFrank
A cheap source of teeth for aquarium gravel
Has Paul McCartney re-recorded Sgt Peppers on his own in order to rid it of the other Beatles’ contributions?
Exactly.
Brian Wilson re-did Smile with zero other Beach Boys.
When did he become a cunt? i have been known to trust your judgement (on some matters) , so i may be swayed by a persuasive answer to this vital question.
god i feel bad now idris. is there anything i can do to rescue the situation?
danny la rouge
More like *fanny* la rouge!
Brian Wilson, for all his fragile genius, is not exactly known for being a nice guy, though.
The39thStep
Urban critical thinker
Tbf his father wasn't either
This is well balanced and insightful, unlike some of the other derisory contributions
danny la rouge
More like *fanny* la rouge!
Indeed. It’s a sad story all round.
Similar threads
