Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Netflix recommendations

I found the same about Archer - watched most of the 1st series, found it a bit repetitive, lost momentum and never went back
 
Apparently Mindhunter's premise is a load of bollocks, so best to treat it as complete fiction, rather than an accurate portrayal of detective work:
The real Mindhunters: why ‘serial killer whisperers’ do more harm than good

Except the series hasn't to date sought to portray itself as 'detective work' and largely focuses on the work of the unit and the tensions created within the FBI about the validity of the method. The Guardian article is however bollock.
 
Except the series hasn't to date sought to portray itself as 'detective work' and largely focuses on the work of the unit and the tensions created within the FBI about the validity of the method. The Guardian article is however bollock.
It's a detective show.
 
Um...was anyone not treating it as a work of fiction??
The criticism is more towards John Douglas, his methods and the claims he makes in the book, than the show itself. Read the article!
I don't think any of it takes away from our enjoyment for the show.
 
It's a detective show.

I can't be arsed to argue but I'd imagine most people wanting a detective show probably expect to see detective related topics like forensics, autopsies, tense tactical discussions, bringing down the criminal, search warrants etc. In other words none of things in this programme. Two of the leading characters aren't even in the FBI.
 
I can't be arsed to argue but I'd imagine most people wanting a detective show probably expect to see detective related topics like forensics, autopsies, tense tactical discussions, bringing down the criminal, search warrants etc. In other words none of things in this programme. Two of the leading characters aren't even in the FBI.
Wevs, it's all the same to me as to call it detective work. Cops/agents in an office trying to work out why people kill people.
 
Wevs, it's all the same to me as to call it detective work. Cops/agents in an office trying to work out why people kill people.

One of the lead characters in an academic, one is a sociology student

But really does it matter? I like the show although it's a bit stylised and a bit ponderous
 
One of the lead characters in an academic, one is a sociology student

But really does it matter? I like the show although it's a bit stylised and a bit ponderous
No it doesn't matter at all but I would still call it a detective show. It doesn't matter if they're not technically detectives. Plenty of crime shows have non-detectives doing similar work. Nosy old biddies, moustachioed Belgians, moustachioed helicopter pilots etc :p
 
I can't be arsed to argue but I'd imagine most people wanting a detective show probably expect to see detective related topics like forensics, autopsies, tense tactical discussions, bringing down the criminal, search warrants etc. In other words none of things in this programme. Two of the leading characters aren't even in the FBI.

It does have all of those things in it!
 
Finished it. Fascinating, gripping, grim and darkly humorous. Not a lot happens, the violence is talked about and hinted at but not seen. It's the interplay between the characters, the atmosphere and the excellent portrayals of various serial killers.
 
I finally got to the end of The Good Place...it has no resolution! I wonder if there are more episodes to come? :confused:
 
The Barkley Marathons is great fun as has already been said.Twenty mins from the end someone in the background quips "this is like 'the Passion of the Christ'" and you know exactly what he means.Never been to the US but access to massive solitudes looks to be excellent-certainly in Tennessee.
 
I couldn't find anything to watch so watched 'Blackfish', which turned out to be a riveting documentary about killer whales that kill in captivity.
 
The Miami Showband Massacre.

A look at that shameful, brutal attack and its legacy. No doubt it's been discredited by some but it makes for haunting and angry viewing.
 
Back
Top Bottom