Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Is Brexit actually going to happen?

Will we have a brexit?


  • Total voters
    362
Noises from France, not much appetite elsewhere.

The biggest opposers historically has been the UK. That particular impediment has effectively ended, but I doubt it will happen.

Dunno, while it's normally given short shrift it's also never been mooted while US and Europe have been so divergent on foreign and defence policy (and relations so toxic on a personal level between the various governments).

The French are looking for a mechanism to get everyone else to pay for and contribute to their assorted wars in Saharan Africa, the Germans are looking for a way to get out of defence spending altogether, and the EU structures are looking for a way to centralise political power - the other side of this however is that the eastern states have absolutely no faith in German promises of military support, the northern EU states have no interest in the Brussels power grab, and the Irish are petrified that they'll be asked to actually have a defence budget.

My own view is that - assuming the € zone doesn't collapse - that this is very much the direction of travel for the EU: the EU is already attempting to set immigration policy, it already has a foreign policy structure, economic policy is being set by the ECB, and there's a nacent defence structure around the EDA.

European military in 5 years? No chance. European military in 30 years? Not an even chance, but heading that way....
 
Dunno, while it's normally given short shrift it's also never been mooted while US and Europe have been so divergent on foreign and defence policy (and relations so toxic on a personal level between the various governments).

The French are looking for a mechanism to get everyone else to pay for and contribute to their assorted wars in Saharan Africa, the Germans are looking for a way to get out of defence spending altogether, and the EU structures are looking for a way to centralise political power - the other side of this however is that the eastern states have absolutely no faith in German promises of military support, the northern EU states have no interest in the Brussels power grab, and the Irish are petrified that they'll be asked to actually have a defence budget.

My own view is that - assuming the € zone doesn't collapse - that this is very much the direction of travel for the EU: the EU is already attempting to set immigration policy, it already has a foreign policy structure, economic policy is being set by the ECB, and there's a nacent defence structure around the EDA.

European military in 5 years? No chance. European military in 30 years? Not an even chance, but heading that way....

“EU AND WHOSE ARMY?” - sometimes Brexit headlines write themselves. :)

Seriously though, I largely agree with your analysis.

One idea is that by having a consolidated European force, the member states will be less on the hook to America, expecting quid pro quo for interventions.

That idea is, for now, running in glue. 27 member states with a range of views, makes things like this incredibly difficult to pass.

So yeah, I think your timeframe verdict and likelihood sound about right.
 
Since this began each time I see ''sovereignty'' it's never made clear for whom exactly.
sovereign t
FoolhardyImaginativeDonkey-max-1mb.gif
 
One idea is that by having a consolidated European force, the member states will be less on the hook to America, expecting quid pro quo for interventions.

Yeah! We can be way less reliant on US imperialism if we go back to good old fashioned European imperialism and THIS TIME we can all work together!


“EU AND WHOSE ARMY?” - sometimes Brexit headlines write themselves. :)

Srsly tho great headline
 
Just read that may will be making a statement at 5.00 (sky feed I think). Not, I imagine that agreement has been reached, more about getting her version in first. Time for a Bingo Card:

  • In the weeks and months ahead
  • Working hard
  • Seeking solutions
  • Difficult issues remain
  • National interest
  • Junker is a pisshead
 
Just read that may will be making a statement at 5.00 (sky feed I think). Not, I imagine that agreement has been reached, more about getting her version in first. Time for a Bingo Card:

  • In the weeks and months ahead
  • Working hard
  • Seeking solutions
  • Difficult issues remain
  • National interest
  • Junker is a pisshead

Acshually, 6.00 or even 7 (grauniad):

May's Brexit cabinet meeting now expected to run at least until 6pm
The cabinet meeting is overrunning, we’ve been told. Theresa May had been expected to make a statement when it finished at around 5pm, but apparently it is now due to run at least until 6pm (ie, for four hours) and perhaps until 7pm (ie, for five hours).
 
Back
Top Bottom