Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Greek elections

“Never wrestle with pigs. You both get dirty and the pig likes it.”-- George Bernard Shaw

the less literary version is, i believe, 'don't argue with an idiot, they take it down to their level and beat you with experience'.

i have no idea, or opinion, as to whether a Pig or an idiot is more appropriate in this instance...
 
the less literary version is, i believe, 'don't argue with an idiot, they take it down to their level and beat you with experience'.

i have no idea, or opinion, as to whether a Pig or an idiot is more appropriate in this instance...

I just thought the conversation was a bit more productive without wading into the ins and outs of the art of negotiation. There is a reason why the negotiations are held behind closed doors after all.

ETA: ... and that's not because it's in the interests of the people.
 
I just thought the conversation was a bit more productive without wading into the ins and outs of the art of negotiation. There is a reason why the negotiations are held behind closed doors after all.

my experience - of carrying bags and handing the tea over to the Ministers Lackeys' Lackey - was that if the negotiations were open for all to see people would decide that a wind up monkey could do the job equally well and at far less expence.

somehow however i rather doubt that thats what happening at the moment - i think a 'free and frank exchange of views' is the accepted term for a shouting match that comes close to fisticuffs...
 
Have our government become involved in this? Seeing as we are owed 10bn by Greece and 'should' have a leadership position within the EU I'm disappointed in our government so far. Not surprised though.
 
i agree entirely - and i'm absolutely not writing as a fanboy for the troikas utterly self-defeating idiocy, merely suggesting that deciding a week before the Greek banking system runs out of money that exit might be on the cards was a spectacularly stupid risk.

Syriza have been at this for 5 months, they must have known months ago that the kind of deal that Greece could live with in the long term was simply not on the cards. had they exited in - for example - April, they could have gone with a cushion of hard currency for imports and allowed the devaluing effect of the New Drachma to kick in for the summer season. as you say, that would mean Greece becoming the cheapest place to holiday in Europe - and, lets be frank, after Tunisia and the continuing turmoil in Egypt, and the endless media stories about Italy and its migrant problems - one of the few safe and desirable destinations in the Med.

The problem is that Syriza weren't in any position to just start announcing that they had decided on a path to leaving the euro, the polls still indicate that most Greeks don't (certainly didn't) want to do this. Syriza's tactics have made this option a politically possible one (and the troika's tactics too of course, who assumed that the Greek population would take fright at it).

So they've changed the game - and I wonder what the Greek polls will say about the euro over the coming weeks. There was never and never will be a good time to crash out of a currency union when you are the weakest element in it and you are negotiating with some extremely powerful countries who have their own reasons for wanting to punish you and whenever it happens, the Greek people will be clobbered for doing it. But what are their alternatives?

On top of this, Syriza's game has revealed the previously latent splits within the troika - most obviously between the IMF and the ECB/EU. The IMF are more-or-less openly supporting the Syriza position now (i.e. that the debt is literally unrepayable).
 
Yes, the main issue is the eurozone being a very silly idea that was apparent to a few at the time (not me, I hasten to add), but proper negotiation is the art of the possible in the here and now.

After the dust settles you can try and learn some lessons but until you have agreement, you need to act with a little more pragmatism.


It's quite clear that Syriza's tactics - and that includes their negotiations - have changed the game. So the "art of the possible" includes the "art of what was previously thought impossible".

For someone who's sounding off about Varoufakis's mistakes and academic foolishness in his 'real life' understanding of Game Theory, I'm surprised that you've missed the obvious element of GT in his resignation (with the added little leaks suggesting that Tsipras "told him to go").

He just did Bad Cop, and now we will have Good Cop.

Syriza also just offered a sacrifice before one was demanded, (The Strong Sacrifice, ie one made from a position of - admittedly temporary - strength) thus wrong-footing the troika and preventing them from "demanding" Varofakis's head and making Syriza "comply with" that demand. This makes Syriza "reasonable" and "moderate" in the eyes of the media and the watching EU public, and allows the troika to make a reciprocal sacrifice without losing face.

He'll be back eventually and obviously deeply involved in strategy in the meantime.
 
Have our government become involved in this? Seeing as we are owed 10bn by Greece and 'should' have a leadership position within the EU I'm disappointed in our government so far. Not surprised though.
I think they're waiting for Sarkozy to get reelected so that they can rub his nose in it for full effect:
 
Have our government become involved in this? Seeing as we are owed 10bn by Greece and 'should' have a leadership position within the EU I'm disappointed in our government so far. Not surprised though.

The Greek government has posted a receipt to Whitehall, "Loan of Elgin Marbles, €10b"
 
Have our government become involved in this? Seeing as we are owed 10bn by Greece and 'should' have a leadership position within the EU I'm disappointed in our government so far. Not surprised though.
Rightly staying on the sidelines as we only a peripheral player. If Tspiras blazing saddles hostage gambit works though, expect loads of similar referendums across Africa and South America, all to the detriment of the suits in the City
 
Last edited:
So, if I understand you, your criticism is that he did bad job negotiating? Apart from the alleged leak (which criticism could be leveled at other parties), what did he do wrong in the negotiations? What could he have done better? And, realistically, what would the outcome of better job negotiating have looked like?

In negotiation one gives something to get something. Anything the Greek govt. now offers in now debased in value as they've shown themselves to be not particularly good at delivering on things they previously promised with much arsing about, obfuscation and back tracking. So they now have to offer more to get less.

Donald Trump covers this in some detail in The Art of the Deal.
 
In negotiation one gives something to get something. Anything the Greek govt. now offers in now debased in value as they've shown themselves to be not particularly good at delivering on things they previously promised with much arsing about, obfuscation and back tracking. So they now have to offer more to get less.

Donald Trump covers this in some detail in The Art of the Deal.
let's look at this from another perspective. greece has something the rest of the eurozone wants: a fucking massive debt. if greece doesn't give this money back or some sustainable deal not done, economic and political chaos on the cards for the eu. if a deal done, then all may be well. if i was involved in the negotiations, i think what i would do would be to say, ok, we will revisit the old gold issue now, let's say we write down the greek debt and pay for it with the greek gold. so, with one fell swoop you remove a bone of contention (the greek gold), you remove or reduce a present threat (the vast greek debt) and you leave everyone happier. it's not like the gold matters too much to germany, in that their economy will be strong with or without it (and they get to keep much of it). so a little bit of economic sleight of hand and suddenly the world seems a better place.
 
In negotiation one gives something to get something. Anything the Greek govt. now offers in now debased in value as they've shown themselves to be not particularly good at delivering on things they previously promised with much arsing about, obfuscation and back tracking. So they now have to offer more to get less.

Donald Trump covers this in some detail in The Art of the Deal.

What have Syriza offered and not delivered?
 
I'll make the point explicitly (and aggressively) if you'd prefer: you clearly don't have a fucking clue what you're talking about, again.

That's not a point, nor is it a reasoned argument.

It is, however, an insult, which remarkably, given your intrinsically supercilious nature, you are not very good at articulating in an even remotely entertaining fashion.

It's a bit like being a dunce while trying to act the fool.
 
That's not a point, nor is it a reasoned argument.

It is, however, an insult, which remarkably, given your intrinsically supercilious nature, you are not very good at articulating in an even remotely entertaining fashion.

It's a bit like being a dunce while trying to act the fool.
yeh, but that doesn't rebut Athos' claim that you haven't a clew what you're talking about
 
If Trump is such a great negotiator I would have expected him to have negotiated a haircut that does not leave him the laughing stock of the western world!

thats the cunning plan, everyone is so busy sniggering at whatever-the-hell-it-is-on-his-head that he's probably bought the world for £6.84 and a punnet of Strawberries. he gets home, throws its across the room and laughs maniacly for a solid 20 minutes.
 
Back
Top Bottom