Saul Goodman
It's all good, man
That pretty much sums it up. Less outgassing, more flammable outgassing. Less likely to self combust but more flammable if they do combust.I was, but looks like I was wrong - and tbf you can still find plenty of older articles talking about them being incombustible or inflammable but
How safe are lithium iron phosphate batteries?
Researchers in the United Kingdom have analyzed lithium-ion battery thermal runaway off-gas and have found that nickel manganese cobalt (NMC) batteries generate larger specific off-gas volumes, while lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries are a greater flammability hazard and show greater...www.pv-magazine.com
linking to: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352152X24008739#fig1
“Hence LFP presents a greater flammability hazard even though they show less occurrence of flames in cell thermal runaway tests,” the researchers said."
(published very recently, the edition is dated 15th May 2024!)
So I'm thinking that earlier tests had just been looking at the occurence of flames.
Still harder to make it catch fire than Li-ion as needs a higher temperature, and I think less likely to create a flame itself so needs an external flame, which is why they could create those tests pretty easily.
Thankfully of course, there's nothing else that might cause a spark or fire in a car crash... I suppose that this comes down to protecting the battery from external flames properly, which is definitely a better issue to be dealing with than the internal battery chemistry.
They probably are safer, but I wouldn't want to sleep in the same house as a damaged one. I've seen too many lithium battery fires to trust any of them.
What I think should be obligatory on all EVs is gas detectors in the battery compartment, to warn of any outgassing before It's too late to do anything about it. Granted, you won't always get a warning but the potential for catastrophic failure should dictate the use of all possible safety measures. It all seems a bit wild west at the moment.