Such a tricky one. So many variations and decisions to make depending on what you want your specific needs and dj life is.
Basically every club has a Pioneer mixer and two pioneer nexus CDJs.
To buy all that costs about 6k...and its pretty shit IMO.
I really dislike pioneer and resent their market dominance.
Im also sceptical about the longevity of this kit, both in the fact that CDJs are far from indestructible and also I wonder is there a new tech change coming soon.
I've got rekordbox free version installed purely so I can have a USB stick formatted ready for such a set up. But rekordbox is really crap compared to serato and supposedly you have to rent a copy if you want to use it with a controller. Scam shite. Though I think you do get some cloud storage with that? Which is pretty good tbf. Anyway fuck Pioneer!
And if you dont want to spend 4k on a pair of overpriced CDJs then the all in one controller is a sensible choice for the home...and this too can be a Pioneer if you want to lock in to their crap. The decision to make with controllers is do you get one without a display and connect a laptop running Serato or Rekordbox, or do you get one with a display. Ones with displays are more expensive of course.
Personally I find the display on Serato via a laptop just so good and above all useful that using a small controller display or the shit display on a CDJ feels like a massive step backwards. I'm very much in love with Serato. The fact Serato has/or is trying to be bought by Pioneer fills me with dread.
Like you I've got 1210s and so I need a mixer, which makes me not have a controller. I luv luv luv my Allen and Heath mixer - best mixer I've ever had the pleasure. The fact it is now no longer supported by Serato is another thorn in my side and means I wont update Serato right now. The whole software compatibility with hardware over time thing is another modern bullshit.
With Serato and 1210s you can of course mix using control vinyl for that 1210 experience, and allows for easy switching up to put a real record on. Personally Ive outgrown vinyl completely for mixing.... digital mixing is so much more fun and creative and ....it sounds better
So what I've done is buy two rudimentary numark CDjs, £100 each second hand, and use them with Serato. Theyre really great but dont have a display worth talking about so you need to use with a laptop. It works amazingly for me.
Then in club environments have to prep a Rekordbox USB. Then with one of my DJ crews we all use Serato via 1210s, so that matches nicely. Thats another factor you might want to think about...are you going to be regularly djing with a group of people? What are their set ups? How best to be compatible? Switching between two laptops can have its awkward issues...another topic.
Fact is you can have a permanent home set up with mixer decks and somekind of CDJ AND you can have a more portable controller for when that is useful, AND have a rekordbox USB stick.
Right now Im curious to see what the next two or three years will bring as I have a feeling there's going to be more standardisation and reduction of choice coming.
ive also got this little DJ2GO controller for mixing in bed, on the sofa, on holiday etc. Wicked little thing, about £60 I think. Better still if interested in that get the
Hercules Starlight, thats got a bass fader and a filter, I wish Id got that instead of the DJ2GO.
Presumably as you have 1210s you also have a mixer....so maybe invest in some CDJS of some description?
I think laptop software (Serato or Rekordbox) is just much more fun and involved so I would go for one of those. I dont know about Traktor but Serato is very much superior to Rekordbox IME.
Im not much of a fan of controllers - theyre handy but they feel lightweight, the mixing experience is less satisfying, and the EQ + FX on my A&H mixer just make me never want to use anything else.