Corbyn compares Israel to Isis...

[Lord Camomile]

there is video of part of the exchange:

All I got was something about "working hand in hand"

 

[J Ed]

there is video of part of the exchange:

I can't make out what was actually said that was supposed to be so offensive, those falling over themselves in hysterics on twitter don't seem to know or care what was said and her statement doesn't mention it either since it just refers to it in a very general and innuendo laden way.

 

[J Ed]

Daily Mail has the full video of the comments, they are relatively innocuous and certainly aren't anti-Semitic MP Ruth Smeeth walks out of the party's anti-Semitism event | Daily Mail Online

They don't even appear to refer specifically to the MP that is claiming anti-Semitism.

Guido, Sky and others have edited the video including the audio at the start of the video to make it impossible to hear the early comments.

Disgusting.

 

[NoXion]

Oh fuck not this ridiculous anti-Semitism bullshit again. It was fucking tedious enough the last time.

 

[agricola]

Oh fuck not this ridiculous anti-Semitism bullshit again. It was fucking tedious enough the last time.

At least that was based on comments that were actually made. How is what he said (at least based on what the video in the Mail states) in any way anti-Semitic?

 

[Wilf]

Jeremy Corbyn ate my hamster and quinoa salad.

 

[J Ed]

Jeremy Corbyn ate my hamster and quinoa salad.

What a disgusting anti-Semitic comment, just why do you think that it is acceptable to call for Israel to be pushed into the sea?

 

[not-bono-ever]

I am missing something here yes ?

 

[Ole]

Anti-Semitic comments? Fucking fibbing crybabies.

 

[Wilf]

What a disgusting anti-Semitic comment, just why do you think that it is acceptable to call for Israel to be pushed into the sea?

That's lemmings.

 

[not-bono-ever]

I genuinely didn't realise the arsehole quotient of Labour MP's was so high

 

[rutabowa]

I genuinely didn't realise the arsehole quotient of Labour MP's was so high

It is pretty astonishing

 

[Pickman's model]

I genuinely didn't realise the arsehole quotient of Labour MP's was so high

Curiously the same % as Polish pure spirit abv, 79.9%

 

[DotCommunist]

HR deparment rage. How dare the old fool not go when told! How dare the members elect someone we don't like! half of them haven't even got a degree!

*thornberry tweet*

 

[Lord Camomile]

I'm still not quite sure what has been said. From the sounds of this link from the other thread:

Here's another take on what happened: Labour activist who berated MP Ruth Smeeth says he did not know she was Jewish and denies Momentum links

Cheers - Louis MacNeice

he accused her of working "hand in hand" with the press, specifically the Telegraph, perhaps?

 

[J Ed]

So someone who isn't Jeremy Corbyn and isn't anything to do with Momentum accused this idiot of colluding with the press to undermine Jeremy Corbyn, which she has done publicly already by resigning, and somehow from all that we arrive at Corbyn/Labour = Anti-Semitic

 

[Ole]

I'm still not quite sure what has been said. From the sounds of this link from the other thread:
he accused her of working "hand in hand" with the press, specifically the Telegraph, perhaps?

Let me remove all doubts about all that has been said. You have it right. He accused the MP of working with The Telegraph, against Corbyn.

That's it.

 

[Louis MacNeice]

I'm still not quite sure what has been said. From the sounds of this link from the other thread:
he accused her of working "hand in hand" with the press, specifically the Telegraph, perhaps?

What you can't hear is any anti-Semitic content from Wadsworth or any comparison by Corbyn of Israel and ISIS for that matter...which is where the thread started. It's ugly desperate stuff from the anti-Corbyn voices.

Cheers - Louis MacNeice

 

[J Ed]

Let me remove all doubts about all that has been said. You have it right. He accused the MP of working with The Telegraph, against Corbyn.

That's it.

Have we reached the most pathetic point of the coup yet or do we have any more ground to cover?

 

[Artaxerxes]

What exactly did the guy shout?

 

[butchersapron]

Marc Wadsworth - that is a name i haven't heard in a very long time.

 

[agricola]

Have we reached the most pathetic point of the coup yet or do we have any more ground to cover?

I still think we will see them all walk out of the Commons chamber when he walks in.

 

[Scutta]

How is working hand in hand with a paper antisemitic????

 

[Ole]

Have we reached the most pathetic point of the coup yet or do we have any more ground to cover?

They've yet to call him a terrorist sympathiser. It's coming.

Possibly terrorist collaborator.

I still think we will see them all walk out of the Commons chamber when he walks in.

Good shout. All the playground tricks yet to play still.

 

[J Ed]

How is working hand in hand with a paper antisemitic????

I demand that you retract this comment and issue a condemnation of the Hamas terrorist organisation.

 

[DotCommunist]

How is working hand in hand with a paper antisemitic????

accusation being that the guy by saying that is implicating she's part of the wider joo plot that controls all politics and media- an anti semetic conspiracy theory. Thats whats alleged here, that the guy implied joo conspiracy. Which he didn't so far as I can see.

 

[Scutta]

I demand that you retract this comment and issue a condemnation of the Hamas terrorist organisation.

look it was just a one off

 

[rutabowa]

What exactly did the guy shout?

No shouting, the guy was just talking from the floor. I transcribed the audio from the video:

I saw that the telegraph handed a copy of the press release to Ruth Smeeth MP who we see is working hand in hand…

[at this point someone very near the microphone says “how dare you” so somewhere in these words must be the offense]

 

[Louis MacNeice]

What exactly did the guy shout?

He didn't shout anything. He said that the MP was working with the Telegraph to undermine Corbyn.

Cheers - Louis MacNeice

 

[Ole]

accusation being that the guy by saying that is implicating she's part of the wider joo plot that controls all politics and media- an anti semetic conspiracy theory. Thats whats alleged here, that the guy implied joo conspiracy. Which he didn't so far as I can see.

He's saying he didn't actually even know she was Jewish.

They're entirely projecting the inference of Jewish conspiracy.