Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Accused rapist Ched Evans to be released from prison

Just when you thought this was all dead and buried, the issue just wont die. I see there is a chance that the rapists sister Kylie may be going in to big brother. Another reason bot to watch it.
 
I can't see the new evidence doing much more than just throwing some doubt on the situation maybe making the conviction unsafe etc..

At best(for him) it might quash the conviction and still leave a lot of questions and doubt hanging over him. I mean unless the new evidence shows the victim has lied about her account then the whole scenario is still very dodgy.
 
Of course not. My point was that we should wait to learn what the new evidence is before hoping (or wishing) that Evans could be further punished, as hash tag seems to be keen on.
Quite. Because of of the politics surrounding the definition of rape and this case, it seems people from opposing viewpoints either want to bury him, support him regardless of any new evidence.

He's like society's test case
 
I can't see the new evidence doing much more than just throwing some doubt on the situation maybe making the conviction unsafe etc..

At best(for him) it might quash the conviction and still leave a lot of questions and doubt hanging over him. I mean unless the new evidence shows the victim has lied about her account then the whole scenario is still very dodgy.

We;ll have to wait and see - but I think it's safe to assume that there is new evidence and it is considered substantial, otherwise he could whistle Dixie.
 
Not sure if this is a new witness or expert witness? Can't remember the twists and turns but I think the possibility of both/either have been touched on in the thread at some point.
 
Not sure if this is a new witness or expert witness? Can't remember the twists and turns but I think the possibility of both/either have been touched on in the thread at some point.

Think it has to be a real witness the radio said it needs to be something pretty good to get to appeal stage. Can't think what would clear him. He raped a girl who was almost unconscious from drink.
 
If the witness could provide evidence she wasn't nearly unconscious, and was not too drunk to consent, that could do it, but from my now hazy memory that's not likely to be the case, they'd have interviewed everyone at the hotel I would have thought, any earlier than that isn't adding anything.
 
Back
Top Bottom