Eight years later, the start of a second Trump term augurs an authoritarianism more studied and honed. I am not in D.C. None of the anti-fascist, leftist crowds I know of, who convened en masse in the city for J20 in 2017, are there. There is no plan for a giant carnival of #resistance, à la the Women’s March, either.
While the severe cold, which has forced Trump’s ceremony inside, could be blamed, the weather did not stymie mass protest plans – no plans anything close to the scale of 2017 were made.
D.C. authorities
have said that there are no known threats to the inauguration, and permitted protests are predicted to be far smaller this time around...
I won’t foreclose surprise —
Luigi Mangione reminds us not to — but it’s likely that, even indoors, the inauguration will be a dreadful,
expensive spectacle, drenched in fascist rhetoric and aesthetics, performed without disruption or notable protest.
The quiet is not necessarily a bad thing. There is little point in going to Washington today to register opposition to Trump’s return. Trumpism never left. No one in the halls of power in Washington is listening. And, above all, the terrain on which we fight Trumpist rule is the rough ground of everyday life. It’s where we’re already standing.
The absence of significant counter-demonstrations could be seen to signal a fatalism or acquiescence on behalf of Trump’s opponents — and, for liberal centrists and conservative “never Trumpers,” it may well be.
For left-wing movements, however, back-footed as we might be, skipping inauguration protests this year evinces a sober reckoning with the limits of certain tactics in certain moments, and, at best, a keener focus on where energies will be needed for the struggles ahead.
The last eight years, but particularly the second half of Biden’s presidency, proved what many on the left had feared: Liberal Democrats’ antifascist rhetoric was hollow.The outraged voices of the #resistance to Trump 1.0 have spent the last years pushing Trump-worthy
anti-immigration policies,
throwing trans people under the bus,
backing Israel’s
genocidal war
on Gaza,
fear-mongering over crime rates, and pouring
funds into police budgets rather than meeting people’s needs.
They licensed the very Trumpian politics they had vowed to #resist. Whether Democrats’ rightward appeals were ill-conceived electoral strategies or signs of ideological alignment with Trump is irrelevant; the violent political work done is the same either way.
Democratic Party subservience to Trump’s second-term agenda
started early, with 48 House Democrats
voting alongside Republicans to pass the Laken Riley Act last week.
The bill would allow immigration officials to indefinitely detain and potentially deport unauthorized immigrants accused — not even convicted — of minor crimes like shoplifting. And it would let the most Trumpist forces in American politics
choose who to deport.
At this point, it is hardly news that we cannot rely on centrist liberals to form an antifascist front. I say this with no joy: Democratic mayors and governors, from New York to Atlanta, have all but signaled that they will offer no institutional protections for communities most vulnerable to Trump’s violent agenda. The left is small and disarticulated. The challenges we face are enormous and growing.
We find ourselves in a grimly defensive position. The task is urgent to build resilient communities, including
rapid-response networks to defend neighbors and colleagues from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, or ensuring the wide circulation and accessibility of
abortion pills and hormones.
Front-line communities have been doing this work — and long before Trump’s initial rise to power too.
Lest anyone forget, the pre-Trump years were no panacea for abortion access, immigrant rights, or health care, especially gender-affirming health care. Fossil fuel capitalism, austerity, brutal inequalities, and worker exploitation,
racist policing, and the
carceral state — these were the conditions of disaffection in which the far-right could thrive.
Now, if Trump delivers even a fragment of the authoritarian promises he has made, all these violences will intensify, as will the penalties for fighting them. Things can just get worse. It is a sign of seriousness that many organizers are focusing on community building and various defense strategies, rather than spectacular protests.