MysteryGuest
beyond boring and interesting
Anyone else noticed the way this thread leans heavily towards either repetition or rhythmic deconstruction? We've got Part and Messiaen in the classical corner, electronic music with seven (!) beats in the bar, a fair bit of so-called drone-rock and post-rock (stupid names both, but you know what I mean...).
Any theories on why, or are we all just trying to be clever?
ADD. ADD in terms of music means a love of repetition, because it relieves the fire of anxiety that usually burns away 24/7 in the ADD mind. "Normal" musical structure comes from the same place where people without ADD socially interact with each other - it's a kind of inbetween place that requires participants to somehow let go but simultaneously focus. If you are blessed with an ADD mind, it's incredibly alienating because there's no way you can join in socially in that way. It's like trying to balance plates on a stick balanced on the end of your nose, while acting all casual. So you develop excellently powerful coping strategies, which usually involve being incredibly funny. Also, if you're unable to connect with people in the "usual" way, you're more likely to require strong stimulation in all areas of cultural life in order to achieve the satisfaction/relief normally experienced by "normal" people in a much milder way. Anxiety-induced anhedonia leads to wanting/needing unusually strong stimulation. This can, and does, have a very strong effect amongst creative sorts, which leads to this unusually intense, vibrant and repetitive music. I always remember when I was studying O level music, the strong aversion I felt to sonata form... that ability to gently but persisently hold something in mind in order to contrast it with something else also held gently but persistently in mind... it was practically physically painful. Hated it. Yet loved music. So - hence, intense repetition with depth of musical insight. To this day "normal" music is like nails down a blackboard to me. Of course, thanks to tablets/smart phones/the internet etc everybody's attention is being systematically ruined, in order to hyperstimulate people so that they can continue to buy things. And precisely because of the cheap thrill of internet-based stimulation, most people who post on the internet are going to have "that" (bare, minimal, intense immediate) effect...