Reno
The In Kraut
The Pledge, from 2001, neo-noir by Sean Penn, starring Jack Nicholson and based on the Dürrenmatt "anti-detective" novel, which has seen several adaptations (I've seen the German one from the 50s) It was good but it wasn't the overlooked masterpiece it's reputation would have you believe.
I wished this had starred someone else than Nicholson. It's a low-key performance only by Nicholson's standards, there is something self-regarding and unconvincing about him trying to dial himself down. At the end he has a slack jawed expression of surprise at the outcome, which he holds for ages, like a beached fish. Another actor would have registered surprise and anguish more subtly.
Penn managed rope in a lot of famous actors for one-scene cameos, which becomes distracting. I think now this would have been made as a lower budgeted independent film or a mini-series for Netflix, relying on character actors rather than on stars, which would have served the material better.
Otherwise Penn's direction is very good, the film is atmospheric and sinister.
I wished this had starred someone else than Nicholson. It's a low-key performance only by Nicholson's standards, there is something self-regarding and unconvincing about him trying to dial himself down. At the end he has a slack jawed expression of surprise at the outcome, which he holds for ages, like a beached fish. Another actor would have registered surprise and anguish more subtly.
Penn managed rope in a lot of famous actors for one-scene cameos, which becomes distracting. I think now this would have been made as a lower budgeted independent film or a mini-series for Netflix, relying on character actors rather than on stars, which would have served the material better.
Otherwise Penn's direction is very good, the film is atmospheric and sinister.
Last edited: