QueenOfGoths
Fuck you Dave!
The Stuart MacBride ones are a bit more, what's the right word, hardcore than the Mark Billingham series. A little like Val MacDiarmid. The next one (for me) in the series has been criticised for being very, very graphic and one of his other novels (A Song for the Dying which isn't a Logan McRae novel) I found quite disturbing.I fancy starting out on a new crime series - which would you recommend between Stuart MacBride's Logan McRae and Mark Billingham's Tom Thorne?
Mark Billingham's novels are very good but don't always hold together in terms of the story, little inconsistencies which mean I keep having to check back with things (though maybe that's just me being anal!) however Tom Thorne is probably a more rounded character than Logan McRae. I was, however, a little disappointed by the last one I read. Mind you the last Stuart MacBride one had some naive descriptions of amateur theatre and the BDSM scene!
I think I would go for the Logan McRae ones, on the whole I've enjoy reading those more.but it's a close thing