I've tried to embrace 'no dig' and low intervention gardening but I admit I'm not always happy with it. Not digging unnecessarily is relatively easy to accomplish for someone as lazy as me but I think I'm too impatient for some of the other aspects.
I try to compost stuff so I have something nutrient rich to provide the plants but my garden isn't that large. I have two traditional compost bins and a hot composting bin but everything takes so long to break down that I have accidentally ended up with a make-shift compost bin for the overspill. Even then, I still end up putting more in the council green waste bin than I should. Perhaps, it's the mix of waste I put in them which slows the process or more likely the fact they are all in the sun (very little shade in my garden) and they dry out too frequently and I forget to water them. I've visited a neighbour's garden which is open under the National Garden Scheme and although their garden is a little larger than mine they must have had a dozen or more compost bins on the go. I simply won't give up that much space to composting.
I accept that bare soil for any length of time isn't good for the health of the soil but I don't like to see cardboard or weed-supressing fabric everywhere. I did it when I moved in and had to clear the garden properly but now I think it just looks untidy. I can't resist the urge to do a bit of light forking on the bare patches so they look 'neat'. I accept this is probably down to coming from a family of avid gardeners (including one professional one) so I've grown up with equating freshly tilled soil with a well-kept garden. The habit is hard to break.
On the subject of bare areas of earth I try to fill my borders with as many plants as possible in the hope that this stops the weeds coming up but with mixed success. I'm still not that good at working out how well certain plants 'do' in my garden and sometimes they overwhelm other plants and then it just looks unkempt. On the other hand, my ground cover plants only seem to disguise the hoards of sycamore seedlings which appear every year and it seems easier to have bare soil to deal with the nascent forest which I appear to be (just about) keeping in check.
Every year I try to wait for the good bugs to out-compete the bad ones but it always seems too late. I get aphids on the lupins, artichokes and runner beans but the ladybirds etc., always seem to be slow to deal with them. I don't kill the leopard slugs but they don't seem to control the other slugs. I have slow worms, the odd frog, the occasional newt or toad but they don't seem to keep the slugs in check either. I see the odd thrush with a snail but they don't seem to tell their mates of the smorgasbord they are missing out on so I have far too many snails. We don't have any hedgehogs and my neighbour says that's down to the badgers. Although my cabbages are covered so the pigeons can't get at them, the slugs and snails appear to revel in the protection of the covers and feast on the cabbages instead.
I do leave most of the leaf-litter from the surrounding trees on the borders but with a mix of sycamore and beech this doesn't seem to decompose as quickly as I'd like so it forms a mat and then you end up with some early plants wearing leaf hats or collars.
I appear to have ranted a bit so it's time I got back to work.