Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Rep of Ireland v Croatia

What's ya predictions?


  • Total voters
    18
I shouldn't bite, I really shouldn't, but here I am anyway.

How was that not an own goal?! Wait, unless you're talking about the first two? :hmm:
I'd say own goal only because it wouldn't have gone in if it hadn't hit his head and changed directions. Nothing he could do about it mind...
 
I'd say own goal only because it wouldn't have gone in if it hadn't hit his head and changed directions. Nothing he could do about it mind...
No, exactly, 'OG' doesn't ascribe blame, just cause. When Gary Neville played it back to Paul Robinson it was a perfectly decent back pass, but it happened to hit a divot, go over Robinson's foot and into the net. That's an OG from Neville - not his fault, but he caused it to go in the back of the net.
 
No, exactly, 'OG' doesn't ascribe blame, just cause. When Gary Neville played it back to Paul Robinson it was a perfectly decent back pass, but it happened to hit a divot, go over Robinson's foot and into the net. That's an OG from Neville - not his fault, but he caused it to go in the back of the net.
I consider that an own goal by Robinson
 
Robinson didn't touch it! It's perhaps Robinson's fault (though I'd actually say even that was a bit harsh) but he did nothing to affect the flight of the ball. If he hadn't been there, the ball would still have gone in.

Though if Robinson hadn't been there you could possibly at that point question Neville's actions :hmm:
 
Back
Top Bottom