How is Amy Winehouse “A bit all over the place”? She absolutely stays in her lane, and her lane is in the main road of music.
And Beyoncé is Beyoncé to the bone. She’s not unpredictable or wayward in any way at all, she even comes up on predictive text with the accent and everything.
What do they mean by a bit all over the place?
They’re both great.
Oh I think they have a point with respect to Winehouse and Beyoncé. Amy Winehouse was bending and using all sorts of qualities in her voice like she's an rnb singer from the 60's. Fantastic but if that style isn't familiar to you and you're looking for familiarity then I can see how it seems sort of wobbly and strange. Beyoncé can be melodically and rhythmically very wayward and then there's her attack, maybe she's a pretty precise singer but she can be very strange as far as chart music goes.