butchersapron
Bring back hanging
Genius - you can't say it was a mistake or you're a twat. You can't say it wasn't or you're a twat. You're an apolitical genius little tommy churchill 
Was it a mistake balders?
Was it a mistake balders?
International Communist Current public forum on world war two, London 14 November
- Thread starter Alfredo
- Start date
Genius - you can't say it was a mistake or you're a twat. You can't say it wasn't or you're a twat. You're an apolitical genius little tommy churchill
Was it a mistake balders?
Can't say.....Ask Pickmans hes like you..He knows everything.....
butchersapron
Bring back hanging
Fantastic
Yet somehow you think you do....and so do the ICC....
but can any of you say what you WOULD have done?
I am just gussing here and its probably a wild one but i reckon if Hitler had a choice between Bomber Harris or General Pickmans in charge......You would have found yourself in charge and lets face it with your record of being thrown out of town halls.............
Genius - you can't say it was a mistake or you're a twat. You can't say it wasn't or you're a twat. You're an apolitical genius little tommy churchill
Was it a mistake balders?
I love your use of the word apolitical there butchers.....great stuff....
You still waiting for Alfredo to come and rescue you?
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
i was waiting for you to reply.
And i did. Now why dont you tell me what you WOULD have done? or are you waiting for Alfredo to tell you?
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
what i would have done when?
You know WW2? I am sure you have an alternative plan all worked out...
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
all of the second world war?
Big subject i know.....but not for somebody who has been chucked out of as many town halls as you surely pickmans......
Please please please tell us what you would have done...
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
in what capacity?
butchersapron
Bring back hanging
But you just destroyed the very concept of historical interpretation balders. Maybe it was an accident?
Leader of all the allied forces....You know just remember how you stormed Hackney Town Hall......How all the people loved you and then double it....
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
source?
FridgeMagnet
Administrator
I remember you storming Hackney Town Hall. I was just trying to pick up some recycling bags at the time, too. 
The International Proletariat Pickmans......Now stop being so modest and tell us how you would have won the second world war.....come on don't be shy.....
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
your premise has no validity.
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
i was in a hurry to get some council papersI remember you storming Hackney Town Hall. I was just trying to pick up some recycling bags at the time, too.
Probably cos as Butchers said i am apolitical......Well to the great and learned like yourselves.......
Maybe i will ask you an easier question.......Why do you think Dresden was an atrocity or a mistake and what should the UK have done instead......
Please try a sensible answer as this is a VERY important thread and we MUST NOT derail it.....
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
i've not said it was a mistake, i was quite definite on that point. as for being an atrocity, i think it's fairly obvious. as for what have been done instead, not bombing dresden's an obvious solution.
But you know the arguements for bombing dresden,hamburg etc.....How can you really say they were wrong?
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
remind me again what they were?
The arguements broadly are all going to be that it was justified because it helped win the war?
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
how did it help to win the war? what concrete results from the bombing of those specific cities helped end the war one day earlier?
You tell me....Your the one who thinks they know....but you seem a bit reluctant to tell us your alternative.
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
why did you bring them up? you're clearly completely ignorant of everything about the bombing of those cities.You tell me....Your the one who thinks they know....but you seem a bit reluctant to tell us your alternative.
Thats why i need a super clever middle class anarchist like you to tell me what should have happened? But you can't,can you?
Pickman's model
Starry Wisdom
the question was "why did you bring them up?"
Similar threads
