Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Absolutely the only single GE 2017 results thread.

I think the first results (Newcastle, Sunderland) will understate the swing to Labour. IMO it'll be more significant in Tory seats in the South.
 
It's the bit they've been saying about not trusting the SNP seat count in the exit poll that is intriguing. If the 22(?) lost SNP seats are losses to Lab or losses to the tories makes an enormous difference. they were saying its 50/50 in a lot of those seats.
 
It's the bit they've been saying about not trusting the SNP seat count in the exit poll that is intriguing. If the 22(?) lost SNP seats are losses to Lab or losses to the tories makes an enormous difference. they were saying its 50/50 in a lot of those seats.
yeah I thought that too - that's a large number of seats to be unknown in this way (given it's only an exit poll anyway etc)
 
Labour shouldn't have to form a government with the help of nationalists or greens. Again, this isn't a great victory for the left.
You need to take into account the starting point. 'Victory for the left'? I'd agree not really. But as a possible vindication of the idea that something other than neoliberal business as usual might actually be palatable to significant numbers of people, it could be quite a major stepping stone.
 
Struggling to breathe, if its right, Tories are weaker, will argue amongst themselves, Corbzn and the left much stronger, Blairites finished.
Nah, the blairites will say Labour would havr got a majority without corbyn.
They've already plotted their next move.
 
Do you know, my own little piece of swing modelling doesn't look as if it was too far off.

I have a little model I've written that allows me to apply various uniform swings to each constituency and also allow a given % of previous non-voters to become Labour votes (proportional to the number of non-voters, not the total population). It makes the potential results look interesting.

330 Tory seats drop to 312 (18 swing to Labour) if you assume that 10% of previous non-voters are now willing to vote for labour.

At a rough guess, I then put in 33% swing from Green to Labour, 20% swing from Lib Dem to Labour, 50% swing from UKIP to Tory, 15% swing from UKIP to Labour and 15% swing from SNP to Tory

That pushes it back up to 329 Tory seats (-1). Labour end up with 246 (+14), but one of those is at the expense of the Green seat, which I don't think will happen. Lib Dem get wiped out from 8 to 2, which again sounds unrealistic. SNP drop from 56 to 51. Tory majority is the result.

It's all very sensitive. If we assume the same swings but 20% of previous non-voters become Labour supporters, the Tories lose 17 and Labour gain 36, with SNP + Labour exactly equal to Tory.

The engagement of previous non-voters is the key, which is exactly the point a lot of us were making when Corbyn became leader and was accused of being unelectable. There are a lot of people out there that can swing it, if they can just be engaged.

I've attached the spreadsheet in a zip in case you want to play with it. I've ordered the constituencies by Labour's closest Tory targets, which makes it interesting.

The "20% of previous non-voters become voters" scenario had the Tories losing 17 and Labour gaining 36. That's very close to the exit polling.
 
Nah, the blairites will say Labour would havr got a majority without corbyn.
They've already plotted their next move.

Aye, they'll be lurking in the shadows now, waiting for the moment where they can bitch as talking heads later on tonight. Won't do them much good if things play out mind.
 
Back
Top Bottom