Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

A thank you to Brexiteers.

Should Ireland gain unification and Scotland gain independence, do you think either will tolerate any re-joining the Union opinions? - I don't.

I don't think they would tolerate any re-joining opinions. Rational people don't fight to give away autonomy.
 
Should Ireland gain unification and Scotland gain independence, do you think either will tolerate any re-joining the Union opinions? - I don't.

I don't think they would tolerate any re-joining opinions. Rational people don't fight to give away autonomy.
Obviously when Ireland is free from the UK it won't be looking to rejoin that union. That's the point of the 6 counties leaving the UK.
 
Nah, I've been completely consistent in saying that workers rights/conditions will be effectively unaltered whether the UK is within/without the supra state, but the negative impacts of withdrawal on ease of trading with remaining EU supra state members is so blindingly obvious that even the most devout leavists accept that truth.

Indeed. Your position is neutral, albeit with a deep concern about the impact of exit on the free flow of capital and goods (and possibly labour).
 
Last edited:
Obviously when Ireland is free from the UK it won't be looking to rejoin that union. That's the point of the 6 counties leaving the UK.

Should Ireland gain unification, the whole of Ireland would automatically be part of the other union. They would have no autonomy. It's a fallacy to think they would have it.

Around Ireland, there would be a border, belonging to the EU. Belonging to Ireland, plus 26 other countries.
 
Last edited:
Every EU member state has autonomy except in areas they may agreeably cede some autonomy for the greater good.
It is a bit like everybody agreeing to drive on the same side of the road for the greater good, and not complaining that they should be able to choose to zig zag all over the place.
Individual member states also have the power of veto in many instances of EU activity and governance.
If somehow there was a United Ireland it would be absolutely fine in the European Union if it so wished to be.
It is the UK that has voted to be cabined cribbed and confined under the auspices of a small group of ultra right evildoers.
 
Every EU member state has autonomy except in areas they may agreeably cede some autonomy for the greater good.
It is a bit like everybody agreeing to drive on the same side of the road for the greater good, and not complaining that they should be able to choose to zig zag all over the place.
Individual member states also have the power of veto in many instances of EU activity and governance.
If somehow there was a United Ireland it would be absolutely fine in the European Union if it so wished to be.
It is the UK that has voted to be cabined cribbed and confined under the auspices of a small group of ultra right evildoers.

Individuals acting in an autonomous way can do things which strip them of any benefit that autonomy would have given them:

Throwing yourself under a bus; Becoming addicted to drugs; Acting in a criminal fashion, and becoming incarcerated.

Acting autonomously to abide by the needs of many countries can be done by treaties. There is no need to adopt an external government, thereby giving away autonomy. It is important that the electorate have a direct link to the governments of their land. Having one, or several, that can go over the heads of the electorate is unhealthy to democracy.

Democracy is in decline. Only 4.5% of the world's population is estimated to be living in a full democracy. The USA was demoted some years ago, and before Trump. Before that, the estimation was 9%, so you can infer from that, that roughly a number the size of the USA population still live in a full democracy. 331 million. The world population is reaching 8 billion.
 
Last edited:
Should Ireland gain unification, the whole of Ireland would automatically be part of the other union. They would have no autonomy. It's a fallacy to think they would have it.

Around Ireland, there would be a border, belonging to the EU. Belonging to Ireland, plus 26 other countries.
We'll hang on all the same, ta. Your Brexit hasn't yielded the glorious results promised. But it has opened up a window of freedom for Ireland. The EU didn't try to wipe out the culture, the language, the religion and brutalize our country.

Good luck with your Brexit all the same.
 
Individuals acting in an autonomous way can do things which strip them of any benefit that autonomy would have given them:

Throwing yourself under a bus; Becoming addicted to drugs; Acting in a criminal fashion, and becoming incarcerated.

Acting autonomously to abide by the needs of many countries can be done by treaties. There is no need to adopt an external government, thereby giving away autonomy. It is important that the electorate have a direct link to the governments of their land. Having one, or several, that can go over the heads of the electorate is unhealthy to democracy.

Democracy is in decline. Only 4.5% of the world's population is estimated to be living in a full democracy. The USA was demoted some years ago, and before Trump. Before that, the estimation was 9%, so you can infer from that, that roughly a number the size of the USA population still live in a full democracy. 331 million. The world population is reaching 8 billion.
None of the world's population live in a full democracy. You wouldn't even know one if one nipped you on the arse, being as you can't even tell me what makes a democratic vote without coming unstuck
 
None of the world's population live in a full democracy. You wouldn't even know one if one nipped you on the arse, being as you can't even tell me what makes a democratic vote without coming unstuck

Listen here, you cretin. I don't make up the terms. But if you think the EU is a beacon, you're definitely an idiot.
 
Should Ireland gain unification, the whole of Ireland would automatically be part of the other union. They would have no autonomy. It's a fallacy to think they would have it.

Around Ireland, there would be a border, belonging to the EU. Belonging to Ireland, plus 26 other countries.

tbf you can called the Sea a natural border :)
 
No. You just have an overinflated opinion of your capacity to be intelligent.
By no means, by no means. As Einstein said the difference between genius and stupidity is genius has its limits. And in this thread you've plumbed the depths of abject stupidity, claiming that votes happening in the UK, because they happen in the UK, must be democratic, for example. Claiming that what parliament says is democratic is democratic, even though that body in extremely undemocratic. That the border between the six counties and the 26 in Ireland is a natural border. It's frankly painful seeing you vomit forth such shit, the only saving grace being that I'm sure your parents haven't seen you humiliate yourself so
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ax^
Which doesn't explain the observed discrepancy between independent grocers and supermarkets regarding the availability of tomatoes. I wonder if my local Spar has tomatoes; they certainly had toilet paper during the time when loads of idiots were losing their minds over it. I'll check today when I go and grab lunch.

I'm back from grabbing lunch, and I can report that tomatoes are indeed available at my local Spar.

IMG_20230223_132002[1].jpg

I'm becoming increasingly convinced that these kind of shortages are largely a result of supermarkets being complacent and incompetent. They've had an easy ride ripping off their suppliers until the challenges of Brexit and the Covid pandemic upset their cosy arrangements, and so far they've shown a sluggishness in adapting to the new market conditions.
 
Back
Top Bottom