Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

White civil rights leader has pretended to be black for years

tbf, three and four are plenty old enough for culturally constructed ideas to be taking hold.

A friend of mine was trying to bring up her first daughter without too many limiting gender-assumptions but by the time she was two years old it was obvious that gender idenitification was a very big part of how she was building her understanding of her place in the world.
 
A friend of mine was trying to bring up her first daughter without too many limiting gender-assumptions but by the time she was two years old it was obvious that gender idenitification was a very big part of how she was building her understanding of her place in the world.
Yeah, sounds right. It's surely one of the very first things we latch onto.
 
Yeah, sounds right. It's surely one of the very first things we latch onto.

On the other hand, I think I was about 4 or 5 before I was sure I was a boy*, despite the fact that I would have been called a boy many, many times.

If there wasn't diversity in our instinctive identifications there would not need to be the massive societal conditioning there to enforce the binary, though, I reckon.

* I don't recall ever thinking I was a girl, but did not identify with 'boy' either
 
Seriously? Men have big sciencey brains and can't help raping, it's just in their nature?
Ok - i didnt read it through properly before posting. Some things in there are true though - brain size is different and since taking eostrogen my brain will have begun to shrink. Brain size is not an indicator of intelligence.
 
no, the urban way is not to read what's put before you but to bluster for post after post before saying 'i haven't read it'. falling at the first hurdle is NOT the urban way.
don't see any reason to string this out more than necessary.

I never said I was perfect. :hmm:
 
Bit of a derail, but you've got to be very careful when attributing things like difference in brain size to difference in behaviour. This stuff isn't well enough understood.
I know - and I'd be the first to admit that. There's still lots of research to be done.
 
i know being a trans woman makes me a political football and / or an inconvenient trutb, but i honestly thought my viewpoint had some relevance here. Clearly it doesnt and i dont want to fall out with people so im ducking out of rhis debate now.

It's a bit of a shame because you arrived at a point where the debate (here) had already moved on from tackling the spuriousness of comparing the Dolezal's "transracialism" (with all the falseness that the very term entails) with what transgender people go through and goodness it took long enough to make the point of the difference between what people are, what they choose to be and what people are inflicted on with by society and were talking about the effects on black people and those of mixed race, women, for me, in particular. I certainly did not mean to exclude your voice from the debate and I do apologise for not taking more pains to make that clear. It certainly was difficult enough for me to do it from the racial aspect alone without having had to trawl through the net to find and post links to what transgender people were saying about the danger of the comparison.
When I said I was glad the debate was moving on was precisely because, in business as usual fashion, black and mixed race voices and experiences are being drowned by that other debate that is really about understanding what transgender means.
 
Last edited:
but why do young children choose to be one or the other even without being led? And why do a small number not pick the gender they're expected to?
I don't know. That's a big question that is unlikely to have a simple answer. But politically, I would say that it doesn't matter, that it mustn't matter. That they do so is enough.
 
but why do young children choose to be one or the other even without being led? And why do a small number not pick the gender they're expected to?

I think there is probably a diversity of dispositions as well as diversity in some 'hardware' elements in the brain relating to gender acquisition (gender expectations could be seen as something that is 'acquired' like language, but where certain instincts are primed in order to get the process going).

I think children are 'led' from birth if not before, but even so, you're not dealing with something entirely plastic.

That muddy enough for you? ;)
 
She's also claiming she's a hairdresser, and falls back on that skill to make extra money. Another New York Post article has her claiming her ex husband forced her to make a sex tape.

Is there no end to her fantastic claims?
 
She's also claiming she's a hairdresser, and falls back on that skill to make extra money.

“White people steal what’s yours, and then they sell it back to you.” - Toni Morrison (another great person to interview her)

Why stop at afros, luscious lips and big bums? Why not sell us our own avatars and taglines? We obviously need them.
 
i liked this one

http://thehardtimes.net/2015/06/16/rachel-dolezal-now-claiming-to-be-founding-member-of-bad-brains/

unnamed21.jpg
 
She's also claiming she's a hairdresser, and falls back on that skill to make extra money.... Is there no end to her fantastic claims?

i would like to make a short statement.

i would like to make clear, contrary to media speculation, that i can have never had my hair styled, cut, dyed, or in any way treated by Rachel Dolezal, nor have i ever asked for or recieved any nature of advice on either fashion or 'look' from Rachel Dolezal.

i have never met or conversed with Rachel Dolezal, nor anyone from her circle of family of friends. in the interests of full disclosure, i have been to the United States, but i thought they were a bit nuts.

that is the end of my statement, i will not be answering any questions, nor will i be making any further comment on this issue. i would ask that you now respect the privacy of my family and friends at this difficult time.

thank you.
 
Back
Top Bottom