Reno
The In Kraut
Vertigo is the film that shaped my interest in film more than any other after my dad gave me the book Truffaut/Hitchcock for my 13th birthday and I went in a quest to watch every single Hitchcock film. It may be because Orpheus and Eurydice was my favourite story as child and it's basically a modern update. Until its re-release in the early 80s the film was almost impossible to see in the 70s as Hitchcock had pulled it from circulation together with four other of his best films. I did however manage to see a secret screening at the Munich film museum in the late 70s and it was a genuinely life changing event for me.
While it often gets said that Vertigo is about an erotic or sexual obsession, I think it's really about a romantic obsession, even if the erotic/sexual/fetishistic reading is the more daring or attention grabbing one. What makes the obsession in Vertigo so destructive is that we so often want to change the people we claim to love and that isn't love, it's basically narcissism. I think Scotty genuinely wants to bring a woman back from the dead instead of merely turning her into a fetish object for his sexual gratification and the tragedy is that he is completely blind to the woman in front of him, who was his love all along.
I kind of resent that it has gone to be this hallowed masterpiece now, especially since Vertigo knocked Citizen Kane off the top of the Sight and Sound list. Feels so unoriginal to have Vertigo as your all time favourite film and inevitably it provokes a backlash, because a lot of people can't see what the fuss is about. I still have Marnie though, a Hitchcock film that still seems slightly controversial to claim as one of his best. It's my favourite after Vertigo though and it's a great companion piece, dealing with similar themes and Sean Connery actually is a perv in the film.
While it often gets said that Vertigo is about an erotic or sexual obsession, I think it's really about a romantic obsession, even if the erotic/sexual/fetishistic reading is the more daring or attention grabbing one. What makes the obsession in Vertigo so destructive is that we so often want to change the people we claim to love and that isn't love, it's basically narcissism. I think Scotty genuinely wants to bring a woman back from the dead instead of merely turning her into a fetish object for his sexual gratification and the tragedy is that he is completely blind to the woman in front of him, who was his love all along.
I kind of resent that it has gone to be this hallowed masterpiece now, especially since Vertigo knocked Citizen Kane off the top of the Sight and Sound list. Feels so unoriginal to have Vertigo as your all time favourite film and inevitably it provokes a backlash, because a lot of people can't see what the fuss is about. I still have Marnie though, a Hitchcock film that still seems slightly controversial to claim as one of his best. It's my favourite after Vertigo though and it's a great companion piece, dealing with similar themes and Sean Connery actually is a perv in the film.
Last edited: