Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Station Eleven (post apocalyptic tv show, based on the acclaimed novel)

Reno

The In Kraut
I finished this last night and it's so good, it deserves its own thread, Station Eleven may already be my contender for best tv drama of the year. The acclaimed novel by Emily St. John Mandel has been on my reading list but I never got round to it, so I don't know how it compares. Station Eleven takes place after a flu-like pandemic, which unlike our current one, wipes out most of humanity. The narrative moves back and forth in time from the start of the outbreak to 20 years later when its central character Kirsten, a former child actress, has become the star of a travelling theatre group, who perform Shakespeare to surviving communities.

The show features a large cast of characters, all of them compelling. Some of them die early into the pandemic but as the show keeps going back in time, they remain main characters, something the show does incredibly well and rather movingly. This makes the characters who don't survive the pandemic more than mere casualties, it gives their lives meaning which reverberates through the narrative. One of the shows biggest strengths is that it's never depressing, even considering parallels to our pandemic. It's hopeful that our capacity for creating communities and art can save us and it ends up one of the most moving TV dramas I've seen in quite some time. Thought there are deadly conflicts, the show doesn't divide people into good and evil. For a while it seems to go that way, a point of comparison would be the superficially similar The Stand but here even the most flawed and fucked up characters have the capacity to change.

The cast is outstanding, especially the two actresses who play the central character Kirsten, one as a child and one as an adult. I've been a fan of Mackenzie Davis since the 80s set show Halt and Catch Fire and she's expectedly great here. Matilda Lawler, who plays her as a child, is phenomenal, as good as any performances by a child actor I've seen. A special shout out for the costume design, especially for the Shakespeare productions the "Traveling Symphony" perform, they are great.

This is an HBO show, which is coming to Starz on Amazon at the end of January if you want to be legal about watching it.


 
Last edited:
The show features a large cast of characters, all of them compelling. Some of them die early into the pandemic but as the show keeps going back in time, they remain main characters, something the show does incredibly well and rather movingly. This makes the characters who don't survive the pandemic more than mere casualties, it gives their lives meaning which reverberates through the narrative. One of the shows biggest strengths is that it's never depressing,
Those are two important features of the book, so I’m glad the series manages to replicate them.
 
It’s really important to me that Clark is a John Coltrane fan in the book, so I hope this is referenced in the show.
 
I thought the book was ok. 7 out of 10. Watched the first few episodes of the series and enjoyed them :)
 
It’s really important to me that Clark is a John Coltrane fan in the book, so I hope this is referenced in the show
As I didn’t read the book it’s not something I was looking out for, so I don’t remember. Reading up on the novel, the series makes some changes to plot and characters which readers of the novel may find controversial.

The series is by one of the main writers of The Leftovers where season 1 also was an adaptation of an acclaimed novel. Then that show carried on for two more (highly acclaimed) seasons. I could see them having made changes to be able to extend the plot for further seasons. That said, the show feels self-contained as is and it could stop here, there is no obvious cliff hanger at the end.
 
I've just finished watching it and really enjoyed it, nothing much to add to what Reno said in the first post really, great story, full of great characters really well acted. Switching of timelines worked extremely well as said. There's plenty of people who we saw a little of whose story could be told, or just a continuation of the travelling symphony and the other communities they visit but I hope they leave it there to be honest.

I wonder if knowing Hamlet would have made a difference? I don't know how much subtext or foreshadowing there was or if mattered at all, I assume it didn't matter but maybe there were some things I missed, especially with the play at the end of the series
 
Not read the book, and took the recommendation from here as hadn't heard of it. Downloaded and have watched a few episodes. Not the usual pandemic/apocalypse type of thing I like, but it is very good as has been said.
 
This is good. Will look into this at the end of the month. The only thing that bothers me is having to sign up for yet another streaming service and remembering to cancel it after I've watched the stuff I was interested in.

I met Emily St John when she was touring the book in the UK. She was very interested in the local castle which is round the corner from the bookshop we were in.
 
Wow, that was amazing. Thanks for the heads-up.

Brilliant use of music and great acting by the whole cast. You can tell its made by the same guy as Leftovers.
 
Last edited:
I thought it was hilarious how they had to stop filming shortly after starting due to the pandemic. I bet they were like wtaf?? :confused::rolleyes::D:hmm:
 
I‘d heard good things about this, but then again that has been the case with plenty of series that didn’t grab me. I started watching it this evening, and the first episode wasn’t really doing it for me.

So it was solely because of this thread that I persevered to the end, and started the second. I am very happy I did. On ep 3 now and very much enjoying it. Not what I had expected at all :)
 
For the sake of my wallet it’s good that the streaming services haven’t been so cynical and greedy yet to offer viewers the option to buy the reminder of a series for those who just can’t wait for next week’s episode. If I could legally watch the rest of this now by forking out some money, I would 😊
 
I’m reading the book at the moment. It’s interesting to see how the story has been changed for TV.
 
Got bored at the start of episode two, I'm not persuaded to watch the whole first season on the off-chance that I might like season two.
 
Well, I'm sorry to say that I was a bit disappointed with it. I loved the book and whilst this show was good, there was some emotional connection missing somehow.

I suspect it has to do with the arc of the Prophet (don't think that counts as a spoiler), amongst other things - including intrusive use of music that either overshadowed important dialog and/or was a blunt method of reminding you what you were supposed to be feeling (a pet peeve of mine; have it complement the scene, sure, but don't use it to replace what is lacking from the script or acting).

So overall, 6/10 for me, whereas the book was a 9
 
Finished it the other night. There were quite a few 'sorry, how the fuck was that meant to work?' moments (I suspect doctors need a little more than a positive outlook and good bedside manner) and I'm not really sure the whole thing hangs together, but I enjoyed the ride. Always nice to see Lori Petty and the two actors playing Kristen were both excellent.
 
Back
Top Bottom