Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Revolutionary Islam

aleister crowley wrote a number of short stories under the collective name of 'golden twigs', which if memory serves are available from the excellent wordsworth press, included with his simon iff stories: one or two of which require a strong stomach.

13276089.jpg

he looks like George Dawes there.
 
Didn't you have to sing hymns in assembly every morning like we did? Kum by Yah and all that stuff. Racing through the Lord's Prayer to try and say it quicker and quicker each morning.
We went through a stage of trying to finish any hymns or prayers last - much funnier until the teachers twigged and started handing out detentions.
 
You don't get to tell me I'm culturally Christian.

Yes we do. The kind of atheism you espouse is a specifically Christian form of atheism. Muslim atheists behave and think very differently from you. That should not be surprising, since everything is formed by what it reacts against. Dialectics innit.
 
Yes we do. The kind of atheism you espouse is a specifically Christian form of atheism. Muslim atheists behave and think very differently from you. That should not be surprising, since everything is formed by what it reacts against. Dialectics innit.

So it was you who started this thread.
 
At the risk of encouraging your displacement activity, I'm not sure whether the Latin version of his name was in use at the time of his trial and death, or whether it only came into use later. Something without which I can probably survive until looking it up for myself.
 
At the risk of encouraging your displacement activity, I'm not sure whether the Latin version of his name was in use at the time of his trial and death, or whether it only came into use later. Something without which I can probably survive until looking it up for myself.

Salve deus rex judeaorum innit.
 
Yes we do. The kind of atheism you espouse is a specifically Christian form of atheism. Muslim atheists behave and think very differently from you. That should not be surprising, since everything is formed by what it reacts against. Dialectics innit.
Just how many Muslim atheists are there living in fully Muslim countries ?
 
Yes we do. The kind of atheism you espouse is a specifically Christian form of atheism. Muslim atheists behave and think very differently from you. That should not be surprising, since everything is formed by what it reacts against. Dialectics innit.
muslim atheist, like christian atheist, is a contradiction in terms. even a dozy twat like you should be able to work it out.
 
We've just done this one, Fool.
so you say. but, you may note, christians believe in god. muslims believe in god. atheists do not believe in god. so your saying someone's a muslim atheist is another way of your saying you are a thick wanker.

it is of course perfectly fair to say that atheists in a muslim country may have a different notion of atheism to their counterparts in a christian country. but describing them as muslim or christian atheists is the act of a twat.
 
I truly cannot imagine how it is possible to grow to adulthood and yet remain so entirely, utterly ignorant of the world.

Have you ever been to a Muslim country, Fool?
for someone who affects to be an academic you are remarkably stupid.

there are no fully muslim countries. there are no fully christian countries. there are no fully jewish countries.

a fully muslim country would, by definition, contain no non-muslims - no christians - no jews - no atheists.
 
Bit of clarity here, phil. If you don't consider yourself Muslim, then you're not. It's as simple as that. And insisting on some residual 'cultural' Islam or Christianity or whatever is both denying people their own agency - if they tell you they do not consider themselves 'culturally' any religion, you should take that seriously - and also being massively simplistic about how cultures and cultural identities form - they are about far more than any named religion.

The Council of ex-Mulsims put it well in their manifesto:

We, non-believers, atheists, and ex-Muslims, are establishing or joining the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain to insist that no one be pigeonholed as Muslims with culturally relative rights nor deemed to be represented by regressive Islamic organisations and ‘Muslim community leaders’.

This stuff matters, and people insisting that others have some intrinsic 'muslimness' or 'christianness' about them that they cannot renounce is poisonous, ill-thought-out, dangerous thinking.
 
Back
Top Bottom