ITV v BBC pundit line ups

[Hollis]

He is a miserable shit though (Keane)- wouldn't enjoy spending time in his company

Neither would I probably... but he's good value. Body language is amazing..lol.

 

[The39thStep]

Talks very clear
Very insightful
He has a good manner and puts it over well
His played at the highest level so knows what he is talking about.
Why have you mentioned his a millionaire and he is in the property game ?
Cant see what that has to do with anything about his ability as a pundit.
At least he dont promote food that makes kids obese and makes him even richer like some other Millionaires.
Most agree his one of the best if not thee best, even Liverpool fans that hate him have said so .

I'm not sure that playing at the highest level ensures that anyone knows what they are talking about as a pundit tbh. Football punditry is full of ex players who often have about as much depth and clarity as a muddy puddle. Fair play if you think he talks clear and has a good manner as thats certaintly an improvement on his brother and Michael Owen. Personally I'd take insight as a more important aptitude for a pundit.
Why have I mentioned that he is a property developer? Because that his main source of income.
Lineker equally as smug and no doubt equally as wadded but somehow I wouldn't put promoting crisps as the same as Nevilles refusal to build any affordable housing in his own city. Horses for courses.

 

[Maggot]

Just a shame the other smug millionaire pusher of rubbish food to kids Lineker is still on it.
Neville is by far the best pundit on tv.

I think Lineker is a great pundit too. His advertising crisps has nothing to do with his punditry.

 

[billbond]

I'm not sure that playing at the highest level ensures that anyone knows what they are talking about as a pundit tbh. Football punditry is full of ex players who often have about as much depth and clarity as a muddy puddle. Fair play if you think he talks clear and has a good manner as thats certaintly an improvement on his brother and Michael Owen. Personally I'd take insight as a more important aptitude for a pundit.
Why have I mentioned that he is a property developer? Because that his main source of income.
Lineker equally as smug and no doubt equally as wadded but somehow I wouldn't put promoting crisps as the same as Nevilles refusal to build any affordable housing in his own city. Horses for courses.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, some good points.
As a aside another site i go on are all saying how bad Evera was as a pundit, worst ever seems to be the theme.
I never saw the game or him so cant comment.
Also about the Lady on it Eluka ? and "how all pc bollox tv sport is getting now with her on, all agendas nowdays"
Ive seen her a few times and thought she was quite good tbh.Must be quite hard in some ways to do surrounded by all these male fairly well known name players.
All opinions at the end of the day.
The ones im not keen on are Lawrenson and Keane

 

[The39thStep]

I'm not sure that playing at the highest level ensures that anyone knows what they are talking about as a pundit tbh. Football punditry is full of ex players who often have about as much depth and clarity as a muddy puddle. Fair play if you think he talks clear and has a good manner as thats certaintly an improvement on his brother and Michael Owen. Personally I'd take insight as a more important aptitude for a pundit.
Why have I mentioned that he is a property developer? Because that his main source of income.
Lineker equally as smug and no doubt equally as wadded but somehow I wouldn't put promoting crisps as the same as Nevilles refusal to build any affordable housing in his own city. Horses for courses.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair enough, some good points.
As a aside another site i go on are all saying how bad Evera was as a pundit, worst ever seems to be the theme.
I never saw the game or him so cant comment.
Also about the Lady on it Eluka ? and "how all pc bollox tv sport is getting now with her on, all agendas nowdays"
Ive seen her a few times and thought she was quite good tbh.Must be quite hard in some ways to do surrounded by all these male fairly well known name players.
All opinions at the end of the day.
The ones im not keen on are Lawrenson and Keane

Evra as totally patronising and a dick, but hes always been a dick tbf.Aluka has been a key member of Chelseas womens team and England over the years so it not like they've just picked up the first black woman they've bumped into. Her comments were good I thought but as you say its only opinions. Lawrenson's been past his sell by date for about a decade.

 

[bellaozzydog]

This was fucking astonishing (I just saw it in the background, lodger was watching I’m no football fan)

Evra slammed for 'patronising' Aluko

Jaw dropping, I doubt he’ll get another punt at punditry this World Cup

 

[Supine]

Was embarrassing. That link cut off before the worst bit though

 

[Dandred]

The stream I'm using keep showing all the people in the studio chatting and having make up put on as the adverts are rolling, great fun seeing and hearing them chatting when they don't think the cameras are on.

 

[binka]

Who'd win in a fight between Keane and Bilic? Bilic all day long imo and Keane knows it

 

[1927]

Slaven Bilic just won the world cup of punditry!

 

[billbond]

Who'd win in a fight between Keane and Bilic? Bilic all day long imo and Keane knows it

Nar
Keane would fight dirty

 

[billbond]

Was embarrassing. That link cut off before the worst bit though

why ?
what happened , never saw it

 

[oryx]

Is Danny Baker doing anything for the World Cup? If not, he should.

He did a thing a couple of weeks ago but it was a bit lightweight, though pretty funny in parts.

BBC iPlayer - World Cup Brush Up with Danny Baker

 

[bellaozzydog]

Slaven Bilic just won the world cup of punditry!

An amazing moment, proper cackling when I watched that