I am not without some cynicism myself about all of this, but I fail to see what demanding Adams owns up publicly to IRA membership would achieve? And yes, I know it's about much more than that for those who are opposed to 'Peace Process PLC', but for the most part, in the last few days, the arguments of the 'dissidents' has amounted to a pointless exercise in trying to prove that he was indeed an 'IRA Commander'.
It might not have been completely stage managed certainly was thr psni going thrpugh the motions to be seen to be doing something.
didn't similar scenes play out round about the time of the founding of the provisionals? if it was a choice back then between the aging cathal goulding, with his impeccable republican pedigree, or the young gerry adams, the young idealist, then i think many people here would have gone with adams and the provisionals. however, we're now forty plus years down the line and a lot of things adams and so on assured people would never happen have happened. perhaps the auld dogs have had their day and youth should have its fling.Sort of sums it up all right. What dissidents think they see here, is young idealist facing down a British collaborator. For the overwhelming majority of nationalists it's a republican veteran of impeccable CV (fire-fights, bank robberies, 20 year jail terms, prison break-outs etc) being disrespected by a self-aggrandizing young gobshite who they suspect struggles to get out of bed before 4 in the afternoon.
Not convinced either way? Then ask yourself this question. Who you would honestly want to have your back?
this was the go fuck yourself moment in Ardoyne.
you can see a brief excerpt of the conforntation on video here
http://lockerz.com/u/20723798/decalz/8182429/utv_catch_up_on_utv_live_on_the_utv_pl
Storeys days of intimidating the youth in republican districts are long over .
didn't similar scenes play out round about the time of the founding of the provisionals? if it was a choice back then between the aging cathal goulding, with his impeccable republican pedigree, or the young gerry adams, the young idealist, then i think many people here would have gone with adams and the provisionals. however, we're now forty plus years down the line and a lot of things adams and so on assured people would never happen have happened. perhaps the auld dogs have had their day and youth should have its fling.
[QUOTE="Casually Red, post:
yeh. but your scenario requires, for success, more than a fleeting experience of government in the 6 and the 26. and the way things are arranged in the 6, it is unlikely that one party will utterly dominate stormont.Even without mad conspiracy theories of who's an agent and for how long, where is there to go for SF? Certainly more seats in the Dail, but how wrong was O'Bradaigh in the 86 video posted above, "They've in from the cold, we got them where we want them"?
Where is there to go for SF? Straightforward really. Government North and South is the interim objective. What would that deliver? One it would establish SF indisputably as an all Ireland party. And the only one.
The resulting symbolism, even on it's own, would not be insignificant.
An obvious more or less immediate consequence would be to see-off more or less entirely the partitionist SDLP, opening up the possibility of SF becoming the best supported party in the Six Counties.
This in turn would would be to pose an ever increasing question against the 'reason for being' of an already backs to the wall Unionism.
With Republicans in government on either side, the border would become ever more of an abstract.And with a border looking more and more anachronistic, Britain's continuing interest in what, let's not forget, is a foreign country would inevitably start to move up the national agenda.
It is true of course that events don't to have to pan out in the desired order from a SF point of view; or even with all the pieces in place they mess up as they have done in the recent past, but at the same time the pathway to their medium and long term goals are achievable. Or given time even inevitable. Now none of it has the smell of cordite of course and it may appear too mundane for some, but that only poses a question against the value placed of sovereignty itself.
Ultimately it isn't a question of 'where is there to go for SF' but more about what it's opponents north and south are prepared to do to stop them getting there?
the way things are arranged in the 6, it is unlikely that one party will utterly dominate stormont.
this was the go fuck yourself moment in Ardoyne.
you can see a brief excerpt of the conforntation on video here
http://lockerz.com/u/20723798/decalz/8182429/utv_catch_up_on_utv_live_on_the_utv_pl
Storeys days of intimidating the youth in republican districts are long over .
yeh. but your scenario requires, for success, more than a fleeting experience of government in the 6 and the 26. and the way things are arranged in the 6, it is unlikely that one party will utterly dominate stormont.
Well unless you have a clear majority both sides of the border for reunification it wont work these days self determination trumps everything.
Any other route than democratic referedum isnt happening
Formally, that is indeed the position. But such things are never about numbers. It is more about the process. And the process is proceeding in only one direction. SF ministers north and south would likely prove to be the death knell for unionism as a political entity, precipitating a collapse in morale on t<snip>
Formally, that is indeed the position. But such things are never about numbers. It is more about the process. And the process is proceeding in only one direction. SF ministers north and south would likely prove to be the death knell for unionism as a political entity, precipitating a collapse in morale on that side on a grand scale. For with it would come the recognition that really there is no point in 'keeping calm and carrying on'. That finally, the jig really is up.
Lets be clear here . What Adams..and Joe Reilly and a few other madmen on here goes a lot further than that . Its a dark side of the PSNI thats anti peace process and up to its neck in collusion with the dissident republicans . Thats what theyre claiming .How is Adams going to square the circle of the backing a police force with a dark anti-republican cabal at its centre? ?
didn't similar scenes play out round about the time of the founding of the provisionals? if it was a choice back then between the aging cathal goulding, with his impeccable republican pedigree, or the young gerry adams, the young idealist, then i think many people here would have gone with adams and the provisionals. however, we're now forty plus years down the line and a lot of things adams and so on assured people would never happen have happened. perhaps the auld dogs have had their day and youth should have its fling.
I'm not moaning about his refusal to own up to membership, farcical as it is there are obvious reasons for it. It's stuff like him moaning about having his shoes and tie removed - he wants to both portray himself the victim of an imperialist state whilst also saying 'don't you know who I am' - and ends up able to say nothing. Most of all, there's this little gem:
"My arrest and the very serious attempt to charge me with IRA membership is damaging to the peace process and the political institutions".
Jude Collins' take on the situation...
Of pile-ups and boomerangs
Countered by the citys so call ring of steel, though of course after those bombs the British Goverment caved in and surrendered to sein feins demands and the GFA was signed
If the gfa was a republican victory what would a defeat have looked like?
yeah, hes sounding like Bono . The rebel whos fanatically pro state .
remember there was no attempt to charge him. If the cops wanted to charge him they simply would have done and not given it a second thought . Theres also a lot of media scepticism starting to emerge about his claims he was interviewed for 17 hours a day...think about that for a minute and how perky and prepared he was at his press conference barely an hour after his release . Imagine just working 4 17 hour days in an office or a call centre and giving that type of flawless performance immediately afterwards ? Bullshit .
And more scepticism as to why Gerry Kelly was permitted to visit him during his arduous interrogations ..nobodys allowed to visit you during an interrogation..not even Policing Board members . Why he was apparently allowed to take notes during it .And not forgetting his ubiquitous Twitter account being active during his incarceration .
http://www.thejournal.ie/who-is-using-gerry-adams-twitter-1444161-May2014/
the whole thing stinks of fakery and theres only one person who benfitted from the entire thing, which was easily foreseen . That fake arrest was cleared at the very highest level of the British establishment and British security security services, its not the work of any cabal . And anyone who believes otherwise is an idiot .