Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

D&D confession/tabletop rpg thread

Do you D&D


  • Total voters
    75
The interesting thing is, because of pathfinder, 4e is out of print but 3.5 is easy to get!!
I don't follow you. Seems to be a glut of 3 stuff. Prices for 3.5 material seems to vary, but tends to be more expensive than 4e. Players handbook is my main point of reference there. I think there is much to be said about marketing strategies developed by WOTC and how Paizo seem to have gone the opposite direction. £30 for a handbook for pathfinder seems excessive, but its incomparable in terms of size to any of the other editions.
 
I think that WoC have realised that pathfinder has taken such a big bite out 4E of that they have started pushing 3/3.5 again. A friend of mine is having trouble getting hold of a 4e PHB (I haven't bothered looking myself so..)
 
how does edge of empire compare to traveller?

am looking at starting a space campaign and after looking through the copy of space opera that I brought down from the loft have decided I don't want to spend the next 8 months relearning the rules.
 
how does edge of empire compare to traveller?

am looking at starting a space campaign and after looking through the copy of space opera that I brought down from the loft have decided I don't want to spend the next 8 months relearning the rules.

Well, it's Star Wars so the setting and tone are completely different. Edge of Empire enforces the idea of criminals on a ship (with obligations to keep them moving). In some ways it reminded me of Serenity with blasters. The dice mechanics do allow lots of random elements in terms of advantage and threats, which suits Star Wars' more active style.

If you're looking for something more like Traveller but with less complicated rules, try Thousand Suns or Diaspora. Same kind of classic sci-fi, but with modern design elements. Or the Battlestar Galactica RPG if you want something darker and more up to date, idea-wise.
 
what I want is something relatively easy to play with the option for them to have ships.

I will probably lead them down a firefly type route campaign wise
 
I grabbed myself a copy of the edge of empire beginners box too.

are there any other good box set stuff out there? (i got the red box, the pathfinder box and decent)
 
Edge of Empire beginners set is on the way after I stumbled on this review on Penny Arcade: http://www.penny-arcade.com/2012/12/24/star-wars-edge-of-the-empire

Some dice are covered in symbols that indicate success while others sport the symbol for failure. The various shapes and sizes all have different ratios of these symbols giving you a better or worse chance of racking up success or failures. When you need to make a skill check you grab a handful of the “good” dice. What you grab is determined by your rank in the skill. For example a droid trying to make a mechanics check might grab two green dice (some success on each side) and one yellow die (this thing is covered with fucking success). Now as the GM I start adding the bad dice to the pool. I might toss in one purple die (a few failures) because it’s a simple lock to pick. But maybe the droid is trying to pick it while being shot at by Stormtroopers so I add a red die (a.k.a the fuck orb) which is bristling with failures. Now the player has a handful of good dice representing their skill and some bad dice representing the circumstances of the check. They roll the entire pool and each failure rolled cancels out a success. If there are any success left over then the skill check succeeded. That right there is the core mechanic of Edge of the Empire.

I like the sound of that!

Also, he links to a free follow on adventure, which is cool.

I'm wondering if it's too much for a 7 year old. He's got to grips with the basics of D&D 4th ed...
 
what I want is something relatively easy to play with the option for them to have ships.

I will probably lead them down a firefly type route campaign wise

Well, Edge of Empire does Firefly with blasters fairly well and it is a pretty good system. The only thing I'm not so fond of is that it mechanically locks you into that game style.

As I say, Thousand Suns, Diaspora and Serenity (yes, the game of the movie for Firefly) may scratch similar itches. It's all a matter of taste, really. Hell, you might even enjoy one of the free Mass Effect conversions out there for D6, nWoD, D20 Saga and so on. The setting is filled with small merc/trader/pirate groups looking for work.
 
I grabbed myself a copy of the edge of empire beginners box too.

are there any other good box set stuff out there? (i got the red box, the pathfinder box and decent)

I heard things about Dragon Age (yes of the computer game). I hear the rules are decent (there's a stunt die system) but the setting is apparently a bit pants.
 
I like the sound of that!

Also, he links to a free follow on adventure, which is cool.

I'm wondering if it's too much for a 7 year old. He's got to grips with the basics of D&D 4th ed...

The rules really are nicely simple - about the level of Cinematic Unisystem and Cortex. The die thing, so long as you have people who can riff off it, is great. My test game had players happily throwing out ideas for advantages and threats to happen on them.
 
Just reading through the edge of empire box set

i do like how it does more for roll playing. it's a bit less "i hit it with my axe" although i can imagine that trying to think of things that might be advantages or disadvantages on the fly might be a challange but if the players all throw out ideas i'm sure it can work
 
Just reading through the edge of empire box set

i do like how it does more for roll playing. it's a bit less "i hit it with my axe" although i can imagine that trying to think of things that might be advantages or disadvantages on the fly might be a challange but if the players all throw out ideas i'm sure it can work

Yup, with the right group it works wonders. It also throws in an element of surprise for everyone, which may or may not be to everyone's tastes.
 
I take it this is Saga not WEG. Seems to still be a lot of love for WEG.

The only thing that puts me off SW rpging is being out ranked by some full on nerd. Unfortunately, as someone eager to run a system there is a lot of inertia from not coping with a standard consisting quite highly of in-game knowledge.
 
I take it this is Saga not WEG. Seems to still be a lot of love for WEG.

Nope, Fantasy Flight Games (they of the Arkham Horror and Battlestar Galactica boardgames) picked up the SW license. So far they've brought out a Rebels vs Empire LCG, an X-Wing v TIE Fighter minis game and this SW RPG. It uses non-standard dice, similar to (but less complicated than) the WFRP 3rd ed box set. (SW RPG Minisite here.)

The only thing that puts me off SW rpging is being out ranked by some full on nerd. Unfortunately, as someone eager to run a system there is a lot of inertia from not coping with a standard consisting quite highly of in-game knowledge.

Yeah. One player lent me his galactic atlas to work out games. I was polite about it, but it's Star Wars. I don't need a map, everything is based on the rule of cool and the speed of plot.
 
.......nostlagia.....Between the ages of about 11-14 i played with my two neighbours a bit of
Dark Future
pic516984_t.jpg

darkfuture.jpg


Blood Bowl, which i was very good at IIRC
m1280059_60010999001_BloodBowlMain_445x319.jpg


A fair bit of Warhammer as Orcs. One famous victory I recall involved a lone gretchen taking out some crack Eldar by continuously scoring kills where you could only score a hit by rolling a 6, which happened time after time and they kept missing him in return. In fact I think that wound up my neighbours so much (who went on to do deep military strategy games with hexagons and little tanks on sqaures) we never played again after that :D
SA400010.jpg


My mate got into regional finals in a painting competition. I think some of his figures are in my mums loft

A few games of Paranoia (great game) a couple of D&Ds
paranoia-cover.jpg


Oh an a few trips down to Chislehusrt Caves for some RRPG at Labyrinthe, mainly monstering (which was free and meant you got lots of action in) but also played a beserker a couple of times! I had a foam club lol. As a beserker if there was any chance of a fight you had to storm in. It was pretty stupid, never lasted long. a 14 year old beserker - i got mullered :D
34_Arty_Farty_C.jpg


Happy days on the whole
 
Just remembered i also went to a convention once, and queued to get a signed drawing of...I think his name was BOG...some kind of goblin cartoon thing probably from White Dwarf.
 
Well, my Edge of Empire game died on its arse. One player basically didn't like anything about it (classes, talent trees, special dice) and had had enough after a couple of hours.So that went well.
 
I feel for you SM. Nothing worse than putting in time and players taking to it. A recipe to take it simple if I was you.
 
I feel for you SM. Nothing worse than putting in time and players taking to it. A recipe to take it simple if I was you.

Well, I thought it was a pretty simple game - and I was running off the beginner pack rules!

To be honest, I've been wholly underwhelmed with my gaming experiences in London. I played less at uni and now than I did when living in Cumbria, the official arse-end of nowhere.
I suppose that it's because there's not much else to do in Cumbria of you don't like fighting and shagging sheep...

(If anyone can get to South London and wants to play games, let me know. I'm kinda desperate.)
 
Is there no clubs? Have you tried orcs nest message board? I have used it a few times and got responses, not always what I was asking for, but responses nonetheless.
 
(If anyone can get to South London and wants to play games, let me know. I'm kinda desperate.)
At one point I was traversing across to shepherds Bush for a weekly session (I live in east London) and it just got too much for me and had to knock it on the head. Shame, cos they were really nice fellows and had a good feel for how they played.

I would be up for a urban london d&d all-dayer if numbers and venue were in order.
 
Am browsing the Swedish meetup boards today, but slightly worried that the chances of meeting idiots is awfully high.
 
Am browsing the Swedish meetup boards today, but slightly worried that the chances of meeting idiots is awfully high.

I haven't tried the board (hadn't realised there was one) but I had looked at the clubs. Unfortunately I don't game on Monday evenings because I work long hours and want to go home.

I used to go to Gameforce, that that's been offline for about a year...
 
Back
Top Bottom