Bands with a big reputation that are (musically) shite
- Thread starter Wilf
- Start date
They didn't really have much good stuff after Vitalogy IMO. Eddie did some cool solo stuff though.
That's where I stopped. I didn't really like Vitalogy actually. Probably still have the CD somewhere. Verses and ten got played a lot back in the day though. I heard Even Flow recently and had forgotten how much I liked it.
Try Vitalogy again. It was Dave Abbruzzese's last one with them as drummer and McCready was off in rehab so there's not so much guitar noodling. Much different vibe. Eddie plays a lot more guitar, he's actually quite good.
Karl Masks
Birds Angel Delight
Maybe don't start or post in a thread like this then ffs
krtek a houby
Merry Xmas!
Maybe don't be aggressive in the first place
RainbowTown
Well-Known Member
Pink Floyd Syd Barrett era were top notch, I love all that stuff. From the music I’ve listened to since (admittedly not that much) they seem to veer between being somewhat clinical and and bit too cold for my liking, though David Gilmour is a fine, fine guitarist.
editor
hiraethified
If you think you can go around calling posters a 'cunt' every time your shitty music taste is questioned in a light hearted thread, you're going to look like a ludicrously angry uber-gammon.
Wind your neck in.
PR1Berske
Alligator in chains by the park gates.
I'll agree with some but will defend others.
Nick Cave has become.... difficult....to enjoy of late because personal circumstances (including the death of his son) has turned his output extremely dense and heavy. Earlier stuff is great (though how common is that caveat on this list
)Foos aren't that bad. It's not like Kings of Leon where everything was sandpapered flat, or Maroon 5 who were forced to introduce guest rappers. I believe the lyrics of Foo Fighters songs, whereas with other commercially successful rock bands of late, it just sounds corporate.
editor
hiraethified
I've tried to like Nick Cave. Friends whose taste I admire go on about him all the time but it fails to move me at all. I'm going to try Neil Young one more time because one of my favourite bands keeps namechecking him. I'm not hopeful!I'll agree with some but will defend others.
Nick Cave has become.... difficult....to enjoy of late because personal circumstances (including the death of his son) has turned his output extremely dense and heavy. Earlier stuff is great (though how common is that caveat on this list
Foos aren't that bad. It's not like Kings of Leon where everything was sandpapered flat, or Maroon 5 who were forced to introduce guest rappers. I believe the lyrics of Foo Fighters songs, whereas with other commercially successful rock bands of late, it just sounds corporate.
Pearl Jam (2006). One of my all time favourite albums. Some incredible songs but it also just works as a combined unit. If you’re allowing 2000 as post-2000, though, I’m going to have to do with Binaural, which might be my favourite album of all time.
Karl Masks
Birds Angel Delight
Your hypocrisy is marvellous
I'll agree with some but will defend others.
Nick Cave has become.... difficult....to enjoy of late because personal circumstances (including the death of his son) has turned his output extremely dense and heavy. Earlier stuff is great (though how common is that caveat on this list
Foos aren't that bad. It's not like Kings of Leon where everything was sandpapered flat, or Maroon 5 who were forced to introduce guest rappers. I believe the lyrics of Foo Fighters songs, whereas with other commercially successful rock bands of late, it just sounds corporate.
I find Dave Grohl immensely irritating for some reason. God knows how the Nicest Man in Rock managed to be in a band with the Most Miserable Man in Rock for years.
Nick Cave - never really got him either. But each to their own. I did love the duet he did with Kylie.
cuppa tee
Well-Known Member
so its basically that you dont like these acts rather than any musical ability.
without Beefhearts vocal style Johnny Rotten would not have sounded the same.
without Syd/Pink Floyd Bowies output might have been very different.
editor
hiraethified
I don't like anything about them, The songs, the lyrics, the instrumentation and/or the singer's voice.
Monkeygrinder's Organ
Dodgy geezer swilling vapid lager
I think The Mercy Seat is one of the best songs ever written - intense, lyrically brilliant, noisy as fuck but still with a great tune, rising to a crescendo. Amazing stuff. The rest of his stuff though I can take or leave, mostly it just sounds a bit portentous without quite hitting home for me.
editor
hiraethified
OK, I'll give it a go.
Cheers I will give them a go.
dogboy_hackney
Member
Original post removed Sorry, I got on my high horse, but missed the the main point of this thread. I'm no musician, so am in no position to point the finger. Still can't stand Floyd, Rush, and sundry others 
Last edited:
mojo pixy
...שלא נמצא בשמאל
Well there's where your comparison falls down. Bleach, Nirvana's first record is a manic filthy punk album really and PJ's first, Ten is highly produced stadium rock. There is no comparison. We'll need to agree to disagree
No I totally agree but it wasn't Bleach that did the business for them, it was produced-to-fuck Nevermind which IMO is considerably less punk and more metal/alt rock.
I don't think anyone who loves music would deny that Nevermind is a work of genius though, not just by the band but also Butch Vig's production. Ten was superb too. I do miss the days when there was actually quality guitar music in the mainstream.
PJ unplugged around the same time. This is about as full on as they ever got. This track got cut from the final cut on MTV for Eddie's pro choice bit at the end.
mojo pixy
...שלא נמצא בשמאל
We've come full circle now because I more or less began with the view that Nevermind was where it went wrong and I don't really get how that album could blow up so massively on its musical merits. Nirvana happened to hit some (non-musical) nerve, and it was a cultural phenomenon but not IMO a musical one. I even loved Nevermind at the time, but looking back I really struggle to explain why.
I think 1991 was a quite shit year for rock music tbh, which helped too.
We'll have to agree to disagree again. Cobain was massively into the Pixies and you can hear that. And I can't think of many better ways to open an album than Smells Like Teen Spirit. Even musically. Four chords. Grohl's furious drumming. Nah, you're wrong.
maomao
普費斯
Ignore absolutely anything where he's playing an acoustic guitar. He's only any good when the guitars are loud enough to take the edge off his whining.
editor
hiraethified
You're not selling it to me here.
maomao
普費斯
Zuma, Arc, Ragged Glory. Most stuff with Crazy Horse is good. He has the best electric guitar tone on earth and can write a decent song.
mojo pixy
...שלא נמצא בשמאל
You can't have it both ways
But I'm happy to be wrong, 32 years after the fact I've grown up a lot and understand things now that I didn't then.
AverageJoe
...
Some of the people gently castigated here (Grohl, Vig) collaborate together. This might not be the right place for this but it really does give a good insight into how a song can come together.
Enjoy (or don't).
