Patteran
A nowadays excuse
Clause 4 was put in place by the right of the party - by the fabians ffs - to put a lid on anti-capitalism. It was never anything but rhetoric designed to stop the party splitting. People used to know this before Corbyn. Basic labour history.
Leo Panitch talks about this, doesn't he - the history of Labour as a party of class harmony, not class conflict. Representatives of all classes, including but not limited to the subordinate classes, absorbed easily, happily & permanently into key institutions & structures, etc.