Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

HS2 high-speed London-Birmingham route rail project - discussion

There's plenty of demand on the WCML. It'll be well used assuming it's not wildly more expensive than existing tickets (and imo politics will demand that it's not more expensive, in order that it gets used. In business terms the existing price is what the market will bear, 20minutes isn't worth paying that much more for).
 
It's not about time or costs it's all about capacity, isn't it?

If it went up to Manchester/Leeds the time savings would be significant enough to be worthwhile. Crewe probably too.
But to Birmingham it's about capacity only. iirc it'll take longer to get to London from Wolverhampton after HS2 because they won't be on the fast services anymore so you have to get a slow train to new street, then walk over to curzon street for HS2.
 
Folks - trust me - I spent a good number of years as an Operations Manager on West Coast South and some more years on helping unpick some bad decisions on West Coast Upgrade post 1999. I have some knowledge therefore. Just a bit.

What was there pre -Covid was about as tight as achievable on the Worlds busiest mixed traffic railway. Repeat for emphasis.

I will not bore you with the comprises to get the older timetable in , but it took about 4 years of diplomacy , stress and compromises. It is just a bit more than quicker journeys to Brum.
 
Folks - trust me - I spent a good number of years as an Operations Manager on West Coast South and some more years on helping unpick some bad decisions on West Coast Upgrade post 1999. I have some knowledge therefore. Just a bit.

What was there pre -Covid was about as tight as achievable on the Worlds busiest mixed traffic railway. Repeat for emphasis.

I will not bore you with the comprises to get the older timetable in , but it took about 4 years of diplomacy , stress and compromises. It is just a bit more than quicker journeys to Brum.

Replace all the first class carriages with standard = increased capacity = that'll be £85 million in consultancy fees please.
 
Replace all the first class carriages with standard = increased capacity = that'll be £85 million in consultancy fees please.
One first class carriage only per train. Treble the price. Those daft enough to pay can still enjoy free coffee, the rest of us might have a chance of actually getting a seat.
 
Replace all the first class carriages with standard = increased capacity = that'll be £85 million in consultancy fees please.

Sorry - no lucre there for you - the 11 car Pendolino sets had an extra standard class vehicle inserted , plus the latest refurb converts another 1st class to standard - leaving generally one and a half vehicles for 1st class (the original concept was for 4 1st class vehicles per train)

Of course - the original "idea" was for 3 classes on this and one Cross Country.....
 
For totally personal reasons I have my fingers crossed phase 2b is Canned. Was totally going to ruin my local country park ploughing right through it.
 
For totally personal reasons I have my fingers crossed phase 2b is Canned. Was totally going to ruin my local country park ploughing right through it.
No chance they’d stick it in a tunnel for you like they did for the wealthy Chiltern landowners who didn’t want their view of underwhelming countryside spoiled? Oh...
 
So it’s now £80bn (realistically £150bn) for a high speed link from London to brum?

Stick a tram on the M1 :hmm:
 
the genius part is getting the 3rd class stander to pay for 2nd class tickets
Ah, you've reminded me of the sorely missed Bungle, who would vigorously defend the British practice of selling people overpriced long-distance train tickets that don't even guarantee them a seat for their journey, and might result on the hapless passenger customer sitting on the floor or walking up and down a long trainset hauling luggage and hoping to catch a glimpse of an empty seat somewhere.

Apparently this is perfectly alright and not something one should complain about.
 
Well, ditching bits of HS2 will be welcome news for those who want to push for expansion of motorways and other bits of road network in the area.
 
To be fair, the works at the NEC are for the Interchange station, and at J9 of the M42 is the 3-way junction to Manchester/London.
The line through Kingsbury Park is going to be on a viaduct so while it might be disruptive during construction, it'll have little effect in the long run
 
Back
Top Bottom