Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Game of thrones season 8 [contains spoilers]

Who the fuck is Bran? Why would anyone want him to be King? Why did he send his brother to the wall? Why did they not bother to even try and wrap up character arcs for Sansa, Arya, Grey Worm etc? Nobody feels complete.

The democracy joke was vaguely amusing, if a little out of tone. One of the few redeeming features.

I'm genuinely annoyed by this. Just awful.. I can't find the words. Just dumbstruck with disappointment.
 
My previous criticisms of this season still stand but but I'm not unhappy with where we ended up. All of the main characters left standing have a chance of forging some happiness which feels true to them, even Jon is clearly going to sod off from the wall and go and be in the Far North with the free folk.
 
I don't particularly like how it turned out, but can't really see what else they would have done.

I am looking forward to starting from 1 again at the weekend. Although I'm not looking forward to the standard dropping as I watch through again. I don't know whether being prepared for it is better or worse.
 
It was alright, as far as it could have been given how poorly-paced and often nonsensical the last couple of episodes have been. Some great acting, some nice touches ("Uncle - sit. Please", Arya going off to be Leif Ericsson, Ghost getting a fuss, etc).
But I should have been in bits at some points - I cry at adverts, FFS - and I just wasn't, because no buildup.

Only just managed not to wreck the whole thing. Which is a shame, because it could and should have been so much better.
 
I was fine with "it's only a TV show" up until this. But this was just shit. And maybe it is only a TV show, but when you feel invested in any story, it does piss you off when they offer something this weak to wrap it up. I'm sure I'm already over it, in terms of having any kind of emotional response, but it was still a rubbish end to a bad season. I was rather hoping that season 8 would be great, and then when it turned out it wouldn't be, I was rather hoping the last episode might close down each character in an interesting way. But for so many characters, who had spent the entire series changing, and by the time they actually changed, there wasn't much for them to do. Sansa and Arya, in particular. Bran, to a lesser extent (cos he never developed much of a character). Gendry, Bron, Brienne, Pod. They just all lived happily ever after ruling a city that presumably doesn't have many people left in it. Sure, some of them were involved in the battle of winterfell, but winning fights was never where the dramatic satisfaction came from in the show.

And John Snow going to the wall was such a shit idea. I wasn't desperate for him to be king, but honestly, if that's their best attempt at reaching an unexpected but dramatically fulfilling end, then... I don't know. Thinking about it, if it had been told right, it might not have felt so disappointing. I suppose I can see a smidgen of irony. But it felt ridiculous, because they'd just unanimously elected a king that had no experience of leadership, who punished a loved family member for the crime of killing a genocidal maniac to appease some foreign soldiers who were all leaving anyway. And they did it with some of the clunkiest dialogue ever written.

I'm not gonna go on about this, or keep responding to replies, because going on too much about any film/show/book is quite tedious. But it was shit. Really, really shit.
 
And John Snow going to the wall was such a shit idea. I wasn't desperate for him to be king, but honestly, if that's their best attempt at reaching an unexpected but dramatically fulfilling end, then... I don't know. Thinking about it, if it had been told right, it might not have felt so disappointing. I suppose I can see a smidgen of irony. But it felt ridiculous, because they'd just unanimously elected a king that had no experience of leadership, who punished a loved family member for the crime of killing a genocidal maniac to appease some foreign soldiers who were all leaving anyway. And they did it with some of the clunkiest dialogue ever written.

How he couldn't have just stayed King in the North I dunno? Not as if the North was/is beholden to the rest of Westeros...

Was never going to be a great ending like the Sopranos but it could have been better.
 
from r/freefolk:

590qdv77jaz21.png


:D
 
STUPID FUCKING ARTICLE WITH "WHO GETS THE IRON THRONE?" ODDS DROPED IN FOR NO REASON RUINED THIS FOR ME WEEKS AGO. FUCKING. ARSEHOLES. :mad: :mad: :mad:

Other than that, not bad. As ever, felt very rushed, but still prefer this over the GIGANTIC EPIC BATTLE episodes this season.
 
And John Snow going to the wall was such a shit idea. I wasn't desperate for him to be king, but honestly, if that's their best attempt at reaching an unexpected but dramatically fulfilling end, then... I don't know. Thinking about it, if it had been told right, it might not have felt so disappointing. I suppose I can see a smidgen of irony. But it felt ridiculous, because they'd just unanimously elected a king that had no experience of leadership, who punished a loved family member for the crime of killing a genocidal maniac to appease some foreign soldiers who were all leaving anyway..
How he couldn't have just stayed King in the North I dunno? Not as if the North was/is beholden to the rest of Westeros...
The 'foreign soldiers' would't have left if Jon was just set free; they would have stayed and started a new/continued the old war. He killed their queen, who they'd travelled the world and won the seven* kingdoms for. And they approved of what she was doing, they didn't see her as evil, so weren't about to say "yeah, alright, fair point, call it square?".

To be honest, I was a little surprised they let him get away with staying alive at all.

And yes, maybe Bran, Sansa et al could have said "war it is, then", but surely the whole point is they've seen what war does and want to choose a different way. No-one's happy, as it should be :)


*at the time...
 
Grey Worm: "Yo Tyrion, you talk too much m8"

Immediately lets Tyrion talk for five minutes solid, decide on the new King, and become Hand despite still being under arrest

Tyrion talked a lot, but not enough to explain to the viewer who all the random new people were.
 
Grey Worm: "Yo Tyrion, you talk too much m8"

Immediately lets Tyrion talk for five minutes solid, decide on the new King, and become Hand despite still being under arrest
Yeaaaaahhh. That was... a little off.

"No, don't listen to me, I've humbly come to realise that I'm not as smar... although, if you did want to hear what I thought - I know you said you didn't, but hear me out..."
 
To be honest, I was a little surprised they let him get away with staying alive at all.

Yeah i didn't really buy that as I would have thought the unsullied would have killed Jon immediately they found out he had killed Danny (and Tyrion too for that matter).
I would have thought some time must have passed after Danny dies and the next scene where Sansa, Bran, etc have arrived in KL so fuck knows how they were still alive.

Wasn't the best ending but could have been worse and i still think it is still a great show when taken as a whole.

At least cersei didn't win :cool:
 
I wonder if making bran the king was the writers trying to make people think he would turn into the night king in a twist at the end that doesn't happen? (have to admit the thought crossed my mind :D )
 
Back
Top Bottom