Three times today I logged onto YouTube and theee times I got served up Tommy Robinson. It’s that sort of ethical issue that they don’t seem to give much of a shit about. I mean Tommy Robinson is one thing but serving it up to millions of brains over and over? It’s not even really him proliferating his shite, it’s THEM. It’s that sort of thing and the fact they have whole teams of geniuses tspending their whole days on how to make them more addictive or how someone like Bezos doesn’t seem to give a single fuck that the busy high street is gone and will likely never return with his hand in that somewhat. Just shrug your shoulders and go on rogan. There is ethical issues in variety but few seem to give a fuck (too busy mainlining content to care or do anything about it)
Are you hitting the "Don't recommend this channel" when that shit turns up? I've found that consistently using that feature has eventually trained YouTube to not serve me reactionary bullshit. At least for the main videos; they still occasionally crop up on Shorts.
I do concede though it ain’t all bad. And people are moving away from using them in unhealthy ways I think more and more. Most of my circle now just stick mainly to whatsapp
I really do prefer how YouTube allows me to watch what I want, when I want, without being restricted to a viewing schedule dictated by some broadcasting executive. But there's still a lot of squandered potential within the YouTube model, especially with how it treats creators of quality content in addition to the algorithmic nonsense you've mentioned.
I'd like to think that the tide is starting to turn on social media. Facebook is already considered a platform for old people. Newer platforms like TikTok have yet to run their course, but there is an increasing awareness of how addictive and psychologically damaging social media can be.
For my part I've stopped using the big corporate social media platforms, with the exception of Reddit. But even then I stay away from most of the larger subs, and if the problems with bots, shills, and professional trolls gets much worse then I will serious consider logging out permanently. I don't know if Discord counts, but I use that to stay in touch with family and connect with other players of the video games I enjoy.
What I have noticed in the recent past is the philosophers and critical thinkers are really starting to take it on. Likely have no affect but there are groups of people reframing the whole ecosystem critically and this wasn’t happening at all. It had to happen because we are in the midst of something as powerful if not more so than the Industrial Revolution. When i stare down the bus and not a single person is doing anything other than staring at a monitised reel, then I turn to the philosophers who make me make sense of it because it sure feels dystopian sometimes.
Thing is, from what I remember of life before the internet started dominating everything, people at bus stops weren't living in some pre-lapsarian utopia where they politely debated the finer points of philosophy with each other. They just had their heads buried in books, magazines and newspapers instead, or were wearing Walkmans and staring off in a direction unlikely to catch someone's eye. You might have even spotted someone playing a Gameboy. It's the perfect context for such petty distractions, and I feel that bemoaning people for using the time to play with their phones is to miss the point. I recently had the realisation that the computational power of my modern smartphone made it possible to turn it into a multi-platform retro-gaming device. I can play classic Doom and Quake and run emulators for systems such as the ZX Spectrum and Commodore 64, and I can even connect an Xbox controller so I don't have to be stuck with touchscreen controls, which are usually terrible.
The real dystopian element, I think, is what isn't obvious from glancing at fellow public transport passengers in waiting. The dark patterns that keep people hooked on short-form videos or disinformation outlets, the algorithms that channel reading habits down particular directions. That kind of thing.
NoXion have you read any of Byung Chul Han?
No. I don't mean to offend, but he seems a little too influenced by the kind of Continental philosophers that I personally find rather tedious. But the dominance of the tech giants provides plenty of attackable surfaces for a wide range of philosophical and ideological outlooks.