Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Celebrity Big Brother 2007

Griff said:
All in all a bit grim for Jade. On the short-term.


6 months down the line, it won't affect her in the slightest, she'll be richer than all of us.

yeah, i can't really see this being "the end" for jade. what does she do for a living? appears in celeb-gossip mags and reality-tv programmes telling all about her life. well this is just another stage in her life. for as many headlines saying "boo hiss jade" i'm sure there's just as many people reading them thinking "well she's not all that bad" and "i'd like to hear her side of the story"...
 
I ended up feeling protective of her ffs!

And 2 nights ago I was denouncing her as a witch but seeing an individual go through that was horrible. She was so scared.
 
According to the BBC, "Goody received 82% of the total votes cast." Which means 18% voted to evict Shilpa. 18%, after watching that campaign of bullying and racism; why?
 
danny la rouge said:
According to the BBC, "Goody received 82% of the total votes cast." Which means 18% voted to evict Shilpa. 18%, after watching that campaign of bullying and racism; why?

Dunno. Not everyone thought she was totally innocent throughout. There was a bit of press promoting that idea and some on this thread.

I'm all conflicted.
 
bellator said:
Me thinks Jade is gonna make mega bucks out of this!
Definitely....there will probably be anti-bullying campaigns with Shilpa and Jade in them with Jade saying "you don't have to be a bully forever.i changed...so can you...."
 
PieEye said:
I ended up feeling protective of her ffs!

And 2 nights ago I was denouncing her as a witch but seeing an individual go through that was horrible. She was so scared.
I think C4 have orchestrated this and have really hung her out to dry. Of course the program will continue which means that they obviously couldn't careless about the complaints. I'm not defending Jade or the others, their behaviour 3was reprehensible and Jade was rightly booed, however the program shoudl have been taken off the air in a quiet and dignified manner.

That was certainly uncomfortable viewing.
 
Random One said:
definitely very inconsistent but if BB hadn't been pushed into it by the media madness they may not have addressed it

And in a perverse sort of way this may turn into a good thing.

BB started as an "experiment" into how different people from different backgrounds interact in a closed and controlled and environment. And there has always been some element of pack mentality in all the series - celeb or otherwise.

This series has opened up a massive tin of worms about the way that people interact outside of their social groups. Jade, Danielle & Jo have shown themselves to be nasty, racist and bitchy within a group that they feel comfortable. Similar backgrounds and ethics. Not necessarily racist but ignorant and stupid. And they've shown the sort of things that people say behind closed doors about people who are from a background/culture different to them. People who would say "some of my best friends are black/gay etc.".

I think my biggest problem with all this is that Jade has been set up to be the fall guy . I'm in no sense justifying Jade but I think that Danielle in particular should have to face up to her part in all this. Her clip in the show tonight where she tried to chum up to Shipa smacked of a very media savvy and cynical person trying to pass all the blame onto Jade. And Jo is by no means blameless either.
 
nonamenopackdrill said:
Her diary room thing and conversation with Shilpa seemed staged.
A lot seemed staged. And Jade said something in the interview about something everyone had told her not to say. What was that? Who was the everyone? Housemates? Producers? What?

I wanted Jade to be shown video of Danielle and Jo. Especially Danielle being two-faced, and racist. Because I wanted to see how she reacted, if that aided her understanding. But I guess the production company want to think they've put the racism to rest now that Jade is gone. But in fact the real racist is still in the house.
 
milesy said:
was she told that there's be no crowd? she didn't look even nearly as shocked as i thought she would have done.



I don't think so...but they certainly anticipated it and knew for defo when the eviction result was called at the end of the first programme and there was no crowd noise (and a very vague 'we'll be getting you shortly').

First time ever that they've not used the phrase 'your best bits' either.
 
danny la rouge said:
According to the BBC, "Goody received 82% of the total votes cast." Which means 18% voted to evict Shilpa. 18%, after watching that campaign of bullying and racism; why?

Because Jade's more entertaining to watch on TV than Shilpa? Big Brother's entertainment, after all, and watching Jade picking fights, arguing, and saying incredibly stupid things is more the kind of thing people watch Big Brother to see than Shilpa doing the washing up and smiling sweetly.
 
danny la rouge said:
I wanted Jade to be shown video of Danielle and Jo. Especially Danielle being two-faced, and racist. Because I wanted to see how she reacted, if that aided her understanding. But I guess the production company want to think they've put the racism to rest now that Jade is gone. But in fact the real racist is still in the house.


:cool:
 
sheothebudworths said:
I don't think so...but they certainly anticipated it and knew for defo when the eviction result was called at the end of the first programme and there was no crowd noise (and a very vague 'we'll be getting you shortly').

First time ever that they've not used the phrase 'your best bits' either.


god just at the time you posted that sheo i got a really powerful acrid whiff from the gerbils... coincidence i'm sure :rolleyes:


*goes off to tend to gerbils*
 
PieEye said:
Not everyone thought she was totally innocent throughout.
The thing is, you don't blame the victim of bullying for the bullying - nothing she did deserved the treatment she got. Nothing.

That isn't the same as saying if there had been no bullying we might not have found her annoying, but being annoying doesn't make you deserving of a campaign of bullying. And of the racism Danielle, and to a lesser extent Jo, is guilty of.
 
sheothebudworths said:
I don't think so...but they certainly anticipated it and knew for defo when the eviction result was called at the end of the first programme and there was no crowd noise (and a very vague 'we'll be getting you shortly').

First time ever that they've not used the phrase 'your best bits' either.

I think she did know. She wasn't nearly shocked enough and sources I trust (taps nose) said that whoever was evicted would be talked to in the hour between the shows (hence the shortened highlights package)
 
danny la rouge said:
A lot seemed staged. And Jade said something in the interview about something everyone had told her not to say. What was that? Who was the everyone? Housemates? Producers? What?

wasnt that when she kept talking about what she'd said and the poppadum comment and someone in the audience told her to stop saying it and after that she did?
 
Yossarian said:
Because Jade's more entertaining to watch on TV than Shilpa?
I hope so. I know that's normally the way it works. But I just thought this was different. So different that for me Big Brother has now run its course; I can't imagine watching another series after this one. Where would they go?
 
danny la rouge said:
A lot seemed staged. And Jade said something in the interview about something everyone had told her not to say. What was that? Who was the everyone?

it was someone in the audience telling her not to say "shilpa poppadom" again that jade was referring to.
 
Callie said:
wasnt that when she kept talking about what she'd said and the poppadum comment and someone in the audience told her to stop saying it and after that she did?
Ah, I didn't hear that. Ok, cheers.
 
nipsla said:
I think she did know. She wasn't nearly shocked enough and sources I trust (taps nose) said that whoever was evicted would be talked to in the hour between the shows (hence the shortened highlights package)

There must have been some kind of 'outside world' talking to this time around. FFS!:rolleyes:
 
danny la rouge said:
The thing is, you don't blame the victim of bullying for the bullying - nothing she did deserved the treatment she got. Nothing.

That isn't the same as saying if there had been no bullying we might not have found her annoying, but being annoying doesn't make you deserving of a campaign of bullying. And of the racism Danielle, and to a lesser extent Jo, is guilty of.

no - I wouldn't but Germaine Greer's article in particular showed a different view point. One that explored the possibility that Shilpa's game was irritating and making the girls react to her in such a way that painted her as the victim.

I find that a little far fetched tbh - plus she claims to have had no previous awareness of the show so wouldn't have worked out a game plan that was quite so complex. Plus does she need to win it? She's there to raise her profile and that has certainly happened!

There are people who think she deserved that treatment and not because they are racists - but because they just think she was cynical and acting a role.
 
Back
Top Bottom