The thing about the Prince Regent is that when it changed it lost 95% of its regulars. I am one of the 5% that stayed and I really like it now, especially as the people that run it have always gone the extra mile for us regulars. It, like Ganleys was previously a fairly shit place, crap beer, no food, rampant drug taking (when I first moved to the area, I thought it was a gay pub for the amount of time, blokes stayed in the bogs)! What it did have was good mix of people but I would argue that neither the Regent or Ganleys accurately reflected the community as it was pretty rough, almost all white (or in Ganleys case Irish) so now, its a bit more inclusive. Herne Hill has always been a bit upmarket, most residents tended to ignore these pubs previously, hence the huge increase in attendence, gastropubs, delis etc in the area. Personally, I don't like the Florence as its a step too far for me, groups of well you know the type, slummy mummys and kids are not for me. The Regent has a policy of no kids after 7pm which I think is right. The Half Moon and the Hoot still cater for people who find the Regent Or the Florence uncomfortable and for me the Effra is also fantastic