i rather have enjoyed it. i like the fact that the contestants were invited - don't see why that's scandalous at all. It means that the nasty sneery elements of x factor etc ("let's all laugh at this delusional person") are bypassed. Plus, all the contestants (other than the out of tune girl they didn't really show Jessie choosing) are really good singers - again, unlike x factor.
Was astounded Kerry Eliis agreed to it, though. Kerry Ellis sang Elpheba in 'Wicked' in the west end, ffs - that's one of the hardest female parts in musical theatre. She may not be Ruthie Henshall, but as grinder paraphrased when i explained it to him, it's like someone with one michelin star turning up on Masterchef the Professionals. Wasn't surprised she or the other musical theatre guy didn't go through. Musical theatre is a very particular skill... doesn't mean you'll be any good in another style. Embarrassing for her though.
i can also declare my membership of team Will. Apart from anything else, he's both a performer, songwriter *and* a producer... which best equips him for the task in hand, surely. I'd have chosen him. Tom is an utter ledge and i adored him in this, but his team is a bit 'cruise ship singer'. The public might like them, so he might win, but i can't see worldwide success.
next week looks interesting - reserve judgement on how it will work, but very pleased to see the gorgeous Ana Matronic in the faces of the celeb helpers. I suppose the head-to-head on the same song format allows there to be an emphasis on THE VOICE (!!) as it invites direct comparison of voice.