John Quays
the reverend relapse
acid priest said:I've always been rather out on a limb with those (along with a small group of afficionados who also believe them to be somewhat underrated). What I feel about 'Code: Selfish' is that it strikes a perfect balance and succinctly represents where the Fall were in the years between 'Shiftwork' and 'Middle Class Revolt', while IMO being the equal of any of them. As for 'Levitate', I think it's a gem of an off-kilter oddity - it doesn't sound like anything else they ever did; rather the sound of a band flying by the seat of its pants and chucking every last screwy idea into the pot just for the hell of it before everything imploded. Glorious shit.
As a result of this (and the fact that Smith heroically picked himself up again in the intervening 18 months) I felt that, when it was released, 'The Marshall Suite' was a touch clinical and level headed and as such a tad disappointing. However, time has proven this also to be a blinder, I feel. I mean, there really isn't a bad Fall album, is there? Even those I consider to be the weakest - 'Bend Sinister', 'Middle Class Revolt', 'Cerebral Caustic' and 'Are You Are (sic) Missing Winner' are still classics by most others' standards.
You write well, you begin to convince me with your many words...
But I'm not quite able to put Levitate up in the pantheon. The disappointment it caused me has passed with time to be supplanted by a lack of interest in it. There just aren't any good songs as such, and even after about 200 listens I get all the titles and that mixed up. Aside from 'I'm A Mummy', obviously. I'll agree it's a curiosity and totally different from the rest, but it didn't give me what I want from the Fall Grüppe. Code Selfish puts me infallibly in mind of Extricate, but I prefer the second. CS has some ace touches (lighter... kleptomaniacs) and a couple of top songs (FreeRange, SC Dangerous) but nearly all the rest strike me as somehow underwritten, too lightweight. Incomplete.
I think my out-on-a-limb album is Middle Class Revolt, which was one of the more recent I've actually bought. I just love it, but I'm well aware this isn't generally the case.