I think I'm about 20 hrs into DA:O have done the Sacred Urn quest and loved it! Now am in Orzammar trying to recruit a dwarf.. they seem pretty cool. I'm beginning to like this game a lot.. was a bit slow at the start but things are picking up mow...
I'm hoping I can skip DA:2 as I read that its really bad..any thoughts? I could just watch it on Youtube..
I don't think it's bad at all. It's different. The outspoken voices you hear online are the whiny cry babies. Most people are able to talk about the pros and cons of the game without stamping their feet.
It's shorter. It's more linear. It's pretty. The lip syncing is the best they've ever done (better than DAI), if that's your kind of thing. It certainly is important to the story of DAI (events of DA2 are directly what sets up the context for DAI - and you really, really, really, really, really want to do the Legacy DLC for Very Important Reasons).
Here are the 2 main reasons people call it the worst game ever made and the reason why BioWare clearly hates their fans and are betraying them
* the combat comes in waves - you'll defeat one bunch of baddies, and another wave of them will miraculously abseil in from nowhere
* they reused a lot of dungeon environments rather than make unique ones for every quest - think the bunkers on unchartered worlds in Mass Effect (I mean... it's not like BioWare doesn't have form for this - it even fucking happens in Origins - but apparently it happening in DA2 meant they were literally Hitler)
I understand both of those complaints.
The first one, coupled with the lack of tactical camera combat and the speedier pace of combat made it more difficult for some to play as tactically as they were used to. Does that make it a bad thing? No. It was being directly compared to DAO and other old school RPGs. If it had been a game in its own right and not been following on from DAO, it wouldn't have caused so much of a stir. It's not the perfect combat style, but I know I preferred it to Origins. I understand why some don't. I've played far more tactically and at higher levels in DA2 and had far more fun with combat in DA2 than I ever did in DAO.
The second one isn't the sort of thing that bothers me anyway. It didn't bother me in Mass Effect. It didn't bother me in Origins. I think the reason why it was so noticeable in DA2 was because the game is more linear than Origins, and there are less unique places to go to. It feels quite a bit smaller in scope. That isn't automatically a bad thing, imo. Again, it's being compared to DAO, which is why they are worse than Hitler.
I prefer the process of playing through DA2 to DAO. I enjoy the combat more. The characters are interesting.
Another thing it gets blasted for is the story and the method of telling it. It takes place over the course of 10 years, and 3 acts (plus a prologue of sorts). Each act deals with a different issue, although they come together for the most part. Act 2 is the outlier, and seems to have the least to do with the overarching story (which is mages versus templars), but is still interesting, particularly if you like Qunari and/or Isabela (the same Isabela as the rogue you can talk to in The Pearl in Denerim in DAO). They took a risk with that method of storytelling. It's being relayed after the fact, in a setting that is important to DAI, involving people who are very important to DAI. I think they realised the method of storytelling - over 10 years - wasn't quite as successful. There's also something that happens at the end that makes NO SENSE at all, but if you'd been paying attention to earlier bits of story and to various notes you'd picked up you could make it fit in your head.
Basically, pronouncements of DA2's shittery are very much overstated. I love the game, and most of the time I'd prefer to play that than I would slog through DAO.
DAI brings the best of both games together in terms of mechanics and combat. But more importantly, DA2 gives you HEAPS of information to bring with you into DAI. I would hate to go into DAI not knowing what I know, not having met who I've met. Plus, one of your companions in DAI is also one of your companions in DA2 and it'd be a huge shame not to know who he is ahead of time.
Playing DA2, even just the once, will absolutely, definitely, without a shadow of a doubt, be beneficial to your knowledge going into DAI, and will enrich your experience as a result.
And definitely, whatever you do, get the Legacy DLC.