Gramsci
Well-Known Member
yeah, that's what I thought you meant by 'ludicrous', as in estate agent-/Evening Standard-speak, 'professional' = 'middle class.'
Why this should be makes no sense to me, since it implies 'working class' = 'amateur' - and (in general) my experience of plumbers, electricians etc are that they are professional in terms of their knowledge, skills and aptitude. In fact a hell of lot more 'professional' than some lawyers or building society bods who I have had the misfortune to deal with
In the USA skilled trades would mean you get called middle class. As someone from US said to me recently nearly everyone in US is middle class. Even though its arguable. A lot of them are suffering now. I think its equivalent to "middle earners" here.
Its political in this country. Left over from the deferential society of the the first half of 20 C. Doctors, lawyers etc regarded themselves as a cut above the "hoi polloi". The earnings of these "professionals" put them in higher category than most people.
Thatcherism was clever in that it managed to get votes from the "middle" earners. Not the older professions but the skilled workers like you mention. Most famously sent up by "Loads of Money".
All depends on how class is defined. Its traditional to view society as in simple class terms. Middle / Working class. But advanced Capitalism makes it more difficult to clearly define. (Though this is debated).
This article from the Economist looks at the ways middle class has been defined in UK.