Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

The X Factor 2008

A lot of people forget Eoghan is only 16 and Diana is only 17. Slag their voices sure but not the things they do, as if you were all mature and sensible people with their hormones in control at that age. :rolleyes:


Young singers shouldn't get famous so fast

Michael Jackson
Jimmy Osmond
Lena Zavaroni


Imagine how Eggham or Diana might turn out :eek:
 
it was so sweet when big head boy ran on :)

but fucking hilarious when he was still sobbing half an hour later :D

put on the "xtra factor" thing. his little eyes are still really puffy. :)

and that guy from the darkness is on, completely off his head.
 
i really liked alexandra but for fucks sake can they not try to hols themselves together? :rolleyes: all this wailing gets on my nerves
i am tempted to vote for alex. have i been swept away :hmm:

I mentioned it a few pages earlier, but her mother is in desperate need of a double kidney and pancreas transplant. She never mentions this, but I'm sure it's why she's always crying.

She so deserves to win.

I really don't get JLS. They are fine if you put the telly on mute, but really, they can't sing. I know they can fix that in the studio, but what is the point of having this competition if the real talent doesn't win?

We've already suffered enough with Leon.
 
I'm fucking appalled that JML are in the final over Diana-they're fucking dreary shite. :mad: :mad:

OMG, I can't believe how long Eggham has sobbed for. :D

Sorry, I've just watched this btw, I've not been stewing over it all night.
 
I've noticed that Diana's fanbase seems to have almost completely disappeared in the last couple of weeks - hardly anyone is defending her anymore. I think she did show promise at the early stages, but she got progressively worse instead of better.

Eoghan and JLS are average, at best - Alexandra is the only one with any star quality, a bit like Rhydian last year in that respect.
 
I've noticed that Diana's fanbase seems to have almost completely disappeared in the last couple of weeks - hardly anyone is defending her anymore. I think she did show promise at the early stages, but she got progressively worse instead of better.

Eoghan and JLS are average, at best - Alexandra is the only one with any star quality, a bit like Rhydian last year in that respect.

Her fanbase hasn't fallen away, its just that me and Ed are fed up with trying to educate those on this thread who can't see that she was the most original, talented person in the competition. When we realised we couldnt educate pork we retreated to concentrate on more productive things!:D
 
A lot of people forget Eoghan is only 16 and Diana is only 17. Slag their voices sure but not the things they do, as if you were all mature and sensible people with their hormones in control at that age. :rolleyes:

yeah fair enough, but I don't want another pop twat on the tv every 5 minutes singing shit songs, i'd rather have a decent mature voice where I may actually buy a pop song i.e. Alexandra
 
I'm fucking appalled that JML are in the final over Diana-they're fucking dreary shite. :mad: :mad:

OMG, I can't believe how long Eggham has sobbed for. :D

Sorry, I've just watched this btw, I've not been stewing over it all night.

on last nights performance I don't agree with the JML bit, I thought there second song was second to Alexandra's overall performance. Diana was toss, the second song, ok she was making the song her own, but she sang it like she was half pissed.

Buy her records ? I don't think so, enjoy the taxi ride home love.

Edit: Actually get a bus, with your young persons bus card you can get one, it will be cheaper
 
After initially liking her, I had begun to find Diana annoying. I think, to be fair, she just hadn't had songs that suited her shtick for a long time. I don't think Cheryl really understood what was best for Diana. But it was absolutely right that she went out.

On the other hand, Devil Child has never, ever been good. He is just cringingly, embarrassingly horrible. Lena Zavaroni reincarnated as a Leprechaun. How he got through to the final, I have no idea. There are obviously a load of people who just want to inflict evil on the world. Why would so many people think having a Daniel-O'Donnell-as-a-precocious-child on the telly every week a good thing? I'd rather have seen the old lady who sang "having a gang bang" make it through.

And J20 are just insipidly average. Unremarkable in every way. We're told all the time that they're the best band that's ever been on the X-Factor. God, there must have been some pretty dire bands, then. Or maybe the judges just think if you're going to tell a lie, make it a whopper.

So the only decent thing would be for Alexandra to win. She has a fine, mature voice. She'll have a career where she's given guff and pap to sing, but as has already been said, I'd rather hear someone with talent and maturity singing guff and pap than some pop lightweight.
 
G4 were on X Factor and they had three platinum albums - can't see JLS being that successful, although "best" is very subjective of course.
 
Her fanbase hasn't fallen away, its just that me and Ed are fed up with trying to educate those on this thread who can't see that she was the most original, talented person in the competition. When we realised we couldnt educate pork we retreated to concentrate on more productive things!:D

I think she will go on to be a good artist but she wasn't an x-factor winner.

This sort of competition demands a level of versatility so she was never going to win. In the real world you don't need it. Look at how many artists' songs all sound exactly the same.

With the aid of a very good team around her she has the potential to be a star but she wasn't it yet.

I was glad she was knocked out but that doesn't mean that i hope she doesn't succeed with a successful singing career.
 
yeah, she was getting a little too exaggerated of her own self iyswim....

Although I didnt see last nights, I do hope Alex is the winner... Her voice really is the best of the bunch.
 
Alexandra is not going to win-she should but I don't think she will. Foetus face or JML. Bland bland, bland. :(
 
After initially liking her, I had begun to find Diana annoying. I think, to be fair, she just hadn't had songs that suited her shtick for a long time. I don't think Cheryl really understood what was best for Diana. But it was absolutely right that she went out.

On the other hand, Devil Child has never, ever been good. He is just cringingly, embarrassingly horrible. Lena Zavaroni reincarnated as a Leprechaun. How he got through to the final, I have no idea. There are obviously a load of people who just want to inflict evil on the world. Why would so many people think having a Daniel-O'Donnell-as-a-precocious-child on the telly every week a good thing? I'd rather have seen the old lady who sang "having a gang bang" make it through.

And J20 are just insipidly average. Unremarkable in every way. We're told all the time that they're the best band that's ever been on the X-Factor. God, there must have been some pretty dire bands, then. Or maybe the judges just think if you're going to tell a lie, make it a whopper.

So the only decent thing would be for Alexandra to win. She has a fine, mature voice. She'll have a career where she's given guff and pap to sing, but as has already been said, I'd rather hear someone with talent and maturity singing guff and pap than some pop lightweight.

Mostly agree but Alexandra is dull. Good but dull and will continue to be so, most likely, considering what you say. Diana has the most interesting voice. That said I'd rather she was the front singer of a band than win this and turn out the sort of pap they will give the winner.
 
Mostly agree but Alexandra is dull. Good but dull and will continue to be so, most likely, considering what you say. Diana has the most interesting voice. That said I'd rather she was the front singer of a band than win this and turn out the sort of pap they will give the winner.

Oh, I quite agree with all you said. By the way, you weren't in Somerfield earlier were you? There was a girl I thought I recognised but in the second of eye contact couldn't place her and then realised she looked like you. If it was, sorry if I blanked you. If not, then I am clearly a loon.
 
Her fanbase hasn't fallen away, its just that me and Ed are fed up with trying to educate those on this thread who can't see that she was the most original, talented person in the competition.

In what alternate universe is doing a crap impersonation of Dolores Cranberry considered original? :)
 
Bollocks. Unbreak my heart last night wasn't Alex's interpretation of it, it was a Toni Braxton cover. Eggham is gutted he can't be in Busted and JML are channelling Boyz 2 Men.

I agree the others wear their influences on their sleeve a bit but Diana's is virtually a Stars In Their Eyes impersonation. IMHO the others aren't nearly as bad as that.
 
I'm with the Diana-was-good-but-got-a-bit-annoying camp.

I think she'll have a great career once she gets a good team behind her. And I think her songs will be good, and likeable and without so much of that inflection (right word?) she has, which can grate.

Gotta be Alexandra for the win now!
 
alexandra is a bit dull. it's like leona #2, same style of pop songs and singing.

i wasn't a massive fan of diana, but at least she tried something different.
 
Back
Top Bottom