Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Silent Films

I was disappointed by Metropolis, Nosferatu and Battleship Potempkin. I wanted to enjoy them but if I'm honest they all left me cold. Since Modern Times is a border line case all I'm left with is a set of shorts by Man Ray which I picked up at the Tate when the the Dada exhibition was on. They aren't feature films, but playful little shorts. Reno's recommendations seem intriguing.

I'd recommend watching the Fall of The House of Usher ( it's available on a link I gave around post 10) .
 
playful little shorts.
l1.jpg
 
I was disappointed by Metropolis, Nosferatu and Battleship Potempkin. I wanted to enjoy them but if I'm honest they all left me cold. Since Modern Times is a border line case all I'm left with is a set of shorts by Man Ray which I picked up at the Tate when the the Dada exhibition was on. They aren't feature films, but playful little shorts. Reno's recommendations seem intriguing.


The are probably slightly less accessible than the films I've mentioned, mostly because they concentrate on art direction and cinematography over character. I've never been a fan of Metropolis, despite some stunning imagery its much too long for the trite message it delivers and Battleship Potempkin was hugely innovative in its editing, but is mostly of historical interest now. Nosferatu has the amazing looking Max Schreck and is a great example of German expressionism, but it also is an emotionally remote and a rather slow moving film. Maybe check out one of the films I've recommended. They all look beautiful but are primarily character driven and Pandora's Box and People on Sunday feature more naturalistic performances. I find Sunrise incredibly moving.
 
When I worked at the London Film School, the first term exercise was 3min b/w silent, one day shoot, Bolex, no lights
Really difficult to try and tell a story of that length with no dialogue.
God there was some real dross but then there would be an absolute gem. :)
 
I finally made it over to see The Artist. I thought it was worth seeing, but wasn't the big award worthy film its been made out to be. I think mostly it's gotten that talk because making a silent film (nearly silent) is a brave choice. But, overall the plot was lacking and bit slow in places.

It was well cast. The people really fit the parts well. I've never seen the leading man before, but I wouldn't kick him out of bed for eating crackers (although being French might be a dealbreaker.) He suited the part of the swashbuckling movie hero well and could carry off the darker stuff too. The female lead, "Peppy" was about as peppy as you could ask for. In fact, I got a bit tired of all the grinning after a while.

The supporting cast was stocked full of lead player playing bit parts and obviously enjoying it.

The use of sound was fairly interesting. It's not really a silent movie, its just used sound sparingly and in the right places.

A few bits in the movie were an homage to previous movies. There's a bit where the lead actor is having breakfast with his wife and they pan meaningfully to the grapefruit on the table, hinting that she was going to get it in the face ala Jimmy Cagney. The ending was a bit like the ending of any Ballywood movie you've ever seen.

And yes, The Dog stole the show.
 
Russell Rouse's The Thief is on at 11am on Film 4 today. It's another oddity, filmed in the 50s, but without dialogue. It's a film noir, with Ray Milland.
 
People on Sunday
1345294931_493130957a_z.jpg

Early docu-drama about how a group of young, lower-middle class friends spend a weekend in Weimar Berlin. The film used non-actors and cast them in a partly improvised story. In a break from German expressionist cinema the era is known for, its cinema verite style looks forward to Italian neorealism and the French New Wave. It still is a strikingly modern film, with jump cuts and hand held camera, that feels like going back 80 years in time and being there. The young film makers who made the film, Billy Wilder, Fred Zinneman and Edgar J. Ulmer and the Siodmak brothers, all were forced into emigration by Hitler and they all had notable careers in Hollywood.


It's a film that finds beauty in the little things of life and there is an added poignancy to this seemingly lighthearted film, knowing that soon these young people, full of hope and potential, would soon be deeply affected or ruined by the rise of Third Reich and WWII. There is a wonderful montage sequence that shows people of all ages enjoying themselves on a Sunday, without a care in the world, which now is deeply affecting when you know what was around the corner.

Try and find a version with a modern score by Elena Kats-Chernin, which adds to the film immeasurably.
It comes with with English (sub) intertitles and has the Elena Kats-Chernin score.
 
Back
Top Bottom