I don't lıke to say ıt, but Trıppy has a poınt.
I wasn't taking cup competitions into consideration with that post.
Newcastle are a Championship side. Nothing more.
They're the best team ın the Champıonshıp though.
For me NUFC were a boring very cynical team, thye were more street wise than city and played the ref like a trombone. Alan Smith should have been sent off far earlier imho, as he played all the game on or over the line. Bothroyd was crap but the few chances he did have Smithy was climbing all over him, Chopra also felt his weight on more than one occasion. Not a great performance from city, but atleast we tried to play football. If the game NUFC played is what success is about then fuck it. I remember watching Neath play rugby in the early 80s and thinking that if 9man rugby was what won you games, and it did, then I'd rather not be there to see it!
No he doesn't. Newcastle are not a Premier League side. They are a Championship side.
Just because they have been a Premier League side for the last few years doesn't make them one now. They have lost most of their best players from last season but remain one of the favourites to get promoted - along with Boro and west Brom, the other relegated sides.
Newcastle are a Championship side. Nothing more.
the parachute payments should be scrapped as they artificially affect the championship and lead to a self fulfilling prophecy of the promotion of the relegated clubs.
I take issue with you there. They are a championship team with an extra £15million for 2 years. the parachute payments should be scrapped as they artificially affect the championship and lead to a self fulfilling prophecy of the promotion of the relegated clubs.
If it was being used to strengthen the squad (in our case) then I would say you may have a point, but considering we haven't purchased a soul, our club is in total limbo as regards to a manager/owner, we have a thread bare side at the moment, and Nicky Butt is still getting a game (christ!), along with everyone having us down to do a Leeds, I don't think your point means much.
There is a far bigger divide between the top part of the premiership to the bottom part, than there is in the Championship. I don't think there's much between teams like Cardiff, boro, Sheff Utd, mackems, Hull, Burnley, Wigan, Bolton, WBA etc.
Look at Reading, where were they a few seasons ago?
Surely more mobility between the Champ and the Prem would be good for football as a whole? So I agree that the parachute payments are a daft ıdea. I like the strangely socıalıstıc draft system they have ın the Amerıcan NFL. Don't suppose ıt could be replıcated ın footıe though.
But the money is used to strengthen the squads.
clubs don't lose money from being relegated, they just receive a smaller wedge than if they were in the prem.
So they lose money then.
Or should I phrase it they lose out on money by getting relegated.
As i've said I can't see every relegated team spending this money just on strengthening the squad, if at all. It will be used to cover outgoings, wages, lost gates, lost sponsorship etc.
Did those teams promoted last season all benefit from a bag of money they received by getting relegated?
Bar a typical Newcastle implosion the teams relegated this season are a lot stronger than those last season (Reading, Derby) where are they at the moment? Yo-Yo teams like Birmingham, WBA, boro, mackems are always going to be strong in the championship and shit in the prem, they've got it off to a fine art.
But if you get money for being relegated you have more money than teams that were always in the championship and that isnt fair!
But if the championship teams haven't achieved promotion, why should they get the same money?
as already mentioned, I agree with you, and as I've already mentioned 2 of the teams relegated last year are in the bottom half of the Championship this year and struggling, 2 teams promoted last season did not get this *bonus*.
You are missing the point completely, promoted sides get money for being in the EPL, thats fair enough, but when they drop down they continue to be paid more than other championship teams, that is not fair!
Th 3 teams relegated last season are the top 3 in the championship at present! Whcih 2 teams didnt get the bonus? I dont understand your post.
It seems that city want a £6mil buyot clause and Ledley wants a £4mil one.
I think Ledley's valuation is more accurate and that he really is only worth £4mil.
I think he really is only worth £4 after sunday's performance.
I dont think he is even worth that