Urban cheek said:
What kind of show would you want to see next year? Ive actually enjoyed this one. It HAS been a totally desperate freakshow at times, but if the producers go back to having a more "stable" house, will people watch it?
i think that the thing the BB producers mis-judged this year was the degree to which fans wanted to mock the contestants. basically, people like contestants who are endearing - that can be in a myriad of ways, and has been in the past. the vast enthusiasm for eugene to me is a sign of that desire for an endearing character, which wasn't really fulfilled by anyone else this year.
the BB producers went for the 'EVIL BB' angle, motivated (imo) by the sheer number of wannabe desperate try-hards they are now getting in auditions. most vaguely reasonable people have been put off by previous years - it's become too big for itself, basically! so they're getting lots of people who are desperate to be famous and yet are desperately uninteresting and self-obsessed.
therefore the BB producers decided to go with the 'EVIL' thing in order to mock that desperation, to push them to the limit, in the expectation that viewers would find it amusing to laugh at what lengths people would go to and what crap they would subject themselves to. (box task?!)
however, i think that this misjudged the audience's interests. yes people like a certain degree of goodie/baddie. yes people like a certain degree of gossip, rule breaking, naughtiness, rebellion. yes people like to see Big Brother giving the housemates what-for.
BUT -
people didn't like the cynical atmosphere of this year's BB. the suspicion. the secret tasks, the 'who's a spy', the bitching, the 'nasty' BB ... basically people didn't like the BB producers' overly cynical treatment of their contestants. people wanted to see endearing traits in them - obviously everyone has different views on what that consists of and who is endearing, but most fans do seek and find endearing characteristics in someone or other. this year only eugene was in any way endearing. hence his massive popularity.
this year there was a massive degree of audience scepticism about anything that BB did. i really do think that the producers need to re-build this bond of trust between viewers and the producers if BB is to have a future.