Urban75 Home About Offline BrixtonBuzz Contact

Scottish independence - as an Englishman, am I "wrong" not to give a crap?

I have heard yes supporters claim an independent Scotland can save the Scottish NHS from the creeping privatisation happening in England. It is an interesting line, I am not aware if it is part of the yes campaign, but some yes voters seem to rate it as an argument.
 
Darling does not seem popular in Scotland. (anecdotally)
Well he is hardly popular in England for that matter.
Wonder if he will be replaced.
It would need to be soon, the clock is ticking.
 
Just reading an article by Billy Bragg which raises a good point ?(which may have been raised already on theis thread, but i'm buggered if i'm going to read all 997 messages to find out).

If the Scots gain independence, will we ever be able to prise the Tories out of office? I can't see it happening in the near future, that would swing the majority to Conservative's favour hugely - what a scary thought
 
Just reading an article by Billy Bragg which raises a good point ?(which may have been raised already on theis thread, but i'm buggered if i'm going to read all 997 messages to find out).

If the Scots gain independence, will we ever be able to prise the Tories out of office? I can't see it happening in the near future, that would swing the majority to Conservative's favour hugely - what a scary thought
its about every third page (exaggerating a bit) brogdale came with this. is some debate but the headline on the piece is about right: Rarely since the war would the Scots vote have changed anything -its part of yes' arguement
 
Darling does not seem popular in Scotland. (anecdotally)
Well he is hardly popular in England for that matter.
Wonder if he will be replaced.
It would need to be soon, the clock is ticking.

too late really. replace him, make the campaign look like its in trouble. Don't replace him, continue to haemorrhage support and credibility.

If I were in charge of Bitter Together I woulodn't replace Darling but I'd give him as little as possible to do from now on. Preferably, lock him in an electricity cupboard with a box set of Veep and an X box until the second half of September.
 
will there be some sort of border guard, dressed in black? perhaps based around a barrier or wall? will a son of a british tv political commentator join this watch? will he whilst on a ill fate patrol north of the wall fall in love with a rebellious highland lassie?
who knows?
 
Something interesting is that Scotland will host the Commonwealth games in Glasgow in the summer. Celebrities like Usain Bolt will be present. It could have an effect on the mood which could go in one of two ways.

One way is that Scottish people may take confidence in their ability to put on a world class event and this may reflect in people thinking - yea Scotland it great, it could be independent, cue floaters opting for a yes vote. Or, it could inspire people to think, being part of something greater is a good thing, being part of the commonwealth, being part of Britain, these are good things, it could bolster support for the Union. I really have no idea what effect it could have - but I do think it could have an effect.
 
Something interesting is that Scotland will host the Commonwealth games in Glasgow in the summer. Celebrities like Usain Bolt will be present. It could have an effect on the mood which could go in one of two ways.

One way is that Scottish people may take confidence in their ability to put on a world class event and this may reflect in people thinking - yea Scotland it great, it could be independent, cue floaters opting for a yes vote. Or, it could inspire people to think, being part of something greater is a good thing, being part of the commonwealth, being part of Britain, these are good things, it could bolster support for the Union. I really have no idea what effect it could have - but I do think it could have an effect.
Very little, I'd imagine. Who the fuck takes any notice of the empire games?
 
The overall feeling about the Commonwealth Games is one of irritation at being booted out of our football stadiums so they can use them tbh. That and annoyance at the amount of money that's being poured into a one-off event that's being held in a poor area and that those who actually live there won't be able to afford to go and see.
 
The overall feeling about the Commonwealth Games is one of irritation at being booted out of our football stadiums so they can use them tbh. That and annoyance at the amount of money that's being poured into a one-off event that's being held in a poor area and that those who actually live there won't be able to afford to go and see.

To be fair that was the general feeling in London before the 2012 games. Once things get going attitudes may change, or they may not.
 
To be fair that was the general feeling in London before the 2012 games. Once things get going attitudes may change, or they may not.
Yep. I was about to post exactly the same thing. I was one of the grumblers about the Olympics, but it was great once it got going. I surprised myself by enjoying it, as did loads of people.
 
Actually that raises a point, do we have to keep Galloway if the Scots leave?

Yes, he is an MP for an English constituency and we sure as hell don't want him back, sorry :D

As for the Games, couldn't give a monkeys. Didn't give a monkeys about the London ones either.
 
Last edited:
Actually that raises a point, do we have to keep Galloway if the Scots leave?
Why is that a even worth asking? He lives in England and is an MP for an English constituency. Did you think he'd be deported along with anyone else born in Scotland? Why?
 
Why is that a even worth asking? He lives in England and is an MP for an English constituency. Did you think he'd be deported along with anyone else born in Scotland? Why?

Well it was meant as a joke, albeit a poor one. You know a bit of satire based around the absurdity of some of points that have been raised such as Doctor Who etc. Sorry I inadvertently antagonised, I promise not to do it again.

 
At least they've backed away from the idea that blowing up social housing would be a fun part of the opening ceremony.

safety risks. Chinny recon, I think someone with half a brain put a stop to that madness on a 'shit pr' ground.

also, if the big pull out of scottish orgs from the CBI had not become a story, the beeb would never have suspended its membership. Nuetrality my arse.
 
Back
Top Bottom